“New light” Watchtower magazine leaked from organization weeks ahead of general release

The July 15 2013 Watchtower, which has been leaked weeks in advance of its scheduled release, offers more questions than answers regarding the Governing Body’s “new light”

Three weeks ahead of its expected release date in mid-April, a scanned copy of the July 15 2013 “Study Edition” of the Watchtower was leaked to the office of JWsurvey by a conscientious active Witness within the organization. I have spent the last two days analyzing its contents.

The magazine in question details the “new light” unveiled at the October 5th 2012 Annual Meeting, at which it was announced that the Governing Body is now considered the “faithful and discreet slave” – the spiritual overlords of the nearly 8 million Jehovah’s Witnesses worldwide.

By the time the magazine is finally released, ordinary Witnesses will have waited six months since the Annual Meeting for a written explanation of the new understanding. However, such ones will be disappointed to discover that this key Watchtower (which Bethelites have been instructed by their superiors to study in detail) offers more questions than answers. As many expected, the magazine writers give explanations for key doctrinal understandings that are unsupported and speculative at best.

Here follows a brief overview of the four main study articles…

  • Tell Us, When Will These Things Be? (September 2-8) – This article first whets the appetite of the reader by discussing bible prophecy related to the “Great Tribulation,” which will commence with an attack on religion by the “disgusting thing” (the United Nations) and climax with Armageddon. The article then provides a re-cap of the understanding, held since 1995, that the separation of the sheep and the goats will happen during the Great Tribulation. The writers expand on this to provide “new light” on Christ’s “arrival” as bridegroom. Whereas this was once thought to have occurred in 1918, the arrival of Christ as “master” or “bridegroom” is now scheduled to happen at some point during the Great Tribulation.
  • Look! I Am With You All the Days (September 9-15) – Christ’s parable of the “wheat and the weeds” is applied directly to the long period between 33 CE and Armageddon. The separating work is said to have commenced in 1914, when Christ undertook a period of “inspection and cleansing” of the organization that lasted until 1919, when the Bible Students were approved as being “true Christian wheat.”
  • Feeding Many Through the Hands of a Few (September 16-22) – Christ’s miracle of the loaves and fishes is held aloft as a foregleam of his intentions to appoint only a small group of men over the spiritual feeding work. The article discusses the “apostles and older men” as being forerunners to the Governing Body arrangement. Russell and his associates (pre-1914) are precluded from representing the appointed channel through which Christ would feed his sheep.
  • “Who Really Is the Faithful and Discreet Slave?” (September 23-29) – The article begins by sweeping aside the previous understanding that the faithful slave was appointed in 33 CE, and goes on to explain how the words of the “prophecy” began to be fulfilled only after 1914. The faithful slave is identified specifically as being “a small group of anointed brothers” currently comprising the Governing Body as a “composite slave.” The article concludes by boldly insisting that Christ WILL appoint the Governing Body, along with other anointed Christians, “over all his belongings” when he comes in judgment during the Great Tribulation.

The “disgusting” United Nations – a former partner

The UN has come under fire from Watchtower publications repeatedly over the decades, but rarely has the denunciation been so forthright as in this latest magazine. On page 4 in the first study article, Witnesses are reminded that the United Nations, which is declared to be the modern-day “disgusting thing,” WILL attack Christendom and the rest of “false religion” to signal the outbreak of the Great Tribulation.

Witnesses will be familiar with Watchtower labelling the UN as the “disgusting thing” of Matthew 24:15, but rarely has the assertion been made with such forthrightness that the UN (and not merely its “members”) will be solely responsible for an attack on all religion. Over the last few decades, Watchtower publications have described the UN’s involvement as executioner of false religion in a variety of ways, some more obscure than others…

Question: Who will destroy Babylon The Great?


  • 1975 – “the United Nations” (w75 5/1 pp. 274-275 par. 11)
  • 1976 – “beastlike radical powers from within the United Nations” (gh chap. 16 p. 147 par. 12)
  • 1977 – “The members of the U.N. and other nations not members of it…” (go chap. 11 p. 177 par. 7)
  • 1980 – “the political backers of the United Nations” (w80 7/1 p. 17 par. 23)
  • 1982 – “The ‘ten horns’ of the United Nations ‘beast’” (w82 5/1 p. 18 par. 9)
  • 1985 – “political elements, represented in the United Nations” (g85 4/8 p. 13)
  • 1985 – “antireligious elements within the United Nations” (w85 6/15 p. 18 par. 19)
  • 1987 – “The ten horns [governmental powers within the United Nations organization] that you saw, and the wild beast [United Nations]…” (w87 11/1 p. 28)
  • 1988 – “the nations will use the scarlet-colored wild beast, the United Nations…” (re chap. 35 p. 258 par. 21)
  • 1989 – “the political powers associated with the United Nations” (w89 5/15 p. 6)
  • 1993 – “political elements, including the United Nations” (g93 1/8 p. 12)
  • 1994 – “militarized members of the United Nations” (w94 3/1 p. 20 par. 11)
  • 1994 – “members of the United Nations” (w94 11/1 p. 17 par. 5)
  • 1997 – “the United Nations… will have a principal role” (w97 9/15 p. 19 par. 14)
  • 2005 – “militarized powers within the United Nations” (w05 9/15 p. 19 par. 13)
  • 2013 – “the United Nations” (w13 7/15 p.4 par. 6)

And so the declaration last heard with such conviction in the 70s and 80s is now voiced again in 2013 – namely that the United Nations organization directly (and not necessarily its “members”) WILL attack and destroy false religion.

The Watchtower has once again labelled the UN a “disgusting thing” despite being affiliated with it for nine years as an NGO

This should raise eyebrows among personnel within the UN, whose own Declaration of Human Rights enshrines the “freedom of religion” – a fact noted by the Society in past publications. (g86 10/22 p. 31)

It will also be a source of unending bewilderment to those within the Ex-JW community that Watchtower continues to slam the UN as being a “disgusting thing” despite having enjoyed a formal relationship with it as an NGO (Non-Governmental Organization) between 1992 and 2001. Watchtower only ended its illicit association when it received unwanted exposure from the UK’s Guardian newspaper. (For more information, click here.)

This latest brief foray into attacking the United Nations in the first few pages of the July magazine sets the stage for what is to follow, as the reader is dragged deeper into the murky madness of the doctrinal maze that Watchtower has created, along with its heavily revised organizational history.

An overview of the changes

Before I begin my rundown of the “new light” regarding the faithful slave, I feel it’s important to avoid potential confusion by clarifying elements of the verse in Matthew 24:45-47 and summarizing what the Society claims to be its fulfilment. Here is what the scripture in question says in the New World Translation:

“Who really is the faithful and discreet slave whom his master appointed over his domestics, to give them their food at the proper time? Happy is that slave if his master on arriving finds him doing so. Truly I say to YOU, He will appoint him over all his belongings.”

As you can see, the above verse effectively has two elements to it. First, Christ appoints his faithful slave to watch over his “domestics.” Then, only later, does Christ “arrive” and appoint the slave over all his “belongings.” Clearly, both of these things cannot happen at the same time. One part of the verse is described in the present tense, and the other in the future tense. Therefore, a period of time is implied between these two events. The question, at least as far as Watchtower is concerned, is “when was this time period?”

In an effort to make all of this as simple as possible, I have produced the following table. It shows the new understanding of the “faithful slave” teaching side-by-side with the old one. Feel free to refer to it when reading this article if things get a little too complicated to take in.

Please bear in mind that if you are expecting explanations in this article that do not appear, this is not my fault. Any such frustration should be directed at the Watchtower writers, who have ignored a number of key questions arising from this “new light.” I will do my best to highlight all pertinent parts of the Watchtower that I feel are of interest using selected quotes. However, for reasons of copyright and personal trust, I cannot and will not reproduce the entire article. Readers are reminded that the full article will be available online in PDF format on (or around) April 15th. (Update: the article is now available for download on this link.)

Christ’s “arrival” in 1918 scrapped

It has long been proclaimed by the Society that the references to Christ’s “arriving” as “master” and “bridegroom” in Matthew 24 and 25 occurred in 1918 when he came to inspect his faithful and discreet slave. It was said that the following year, 1919, Christ completed his inspection and decided to appoint the early Bible Students as his faithful slave over all of this belongings.

Under this new understanding, however, 1914 is now earmarked as being the year that Christ began to inspect and cleanse the organization – with this “inspection period” ending in 1919 when Christ supposedly approved the directors of the Watch Tower Society as his faithful slave by appointing them over his domestics.

1918 has therefore fallen by the wayside and lost any real significance – at least as far as the “end time” prophecies in Matthew are concerned. This is made clear on pages 7 and 8 of the new magazine, where we are informed that all eight references to Christ’s “coming” or “arrival” between Matthew 24:29 and the end of chapter 25 refer to the “future time of judgment during the great tribulation.”

An eventful “inspection and cleansing” period

In the minds of many, one of the most intriguing aspects of this new understanding is the fact that Charles Taze Russell, once considered part of the Slave Class, has been effectively written out of having any real biblical significance in Witness history. This is confirmed on page 19, where it says:

“Were the Bible Students in the years that lead up to 1914 the appointed channel through which Christ would feed his sheep? No. They were still in the growing season, and the arrangement for a channel to provide spiritual food was taking shape. The time had not yet come for the weedlike imitation Christians to be separated from the true Christian wheat.” (w13 7/15 p.19)

Christ’s parable of the wheat and weeds (Matt 13:24-30, 37-43) forms the basis of the second study article, entitled “Look! I Am With You All the Days,” and is referenced throughout the magazine, as above. The scripture and its “fulfilment” is explained by means of an illustrative timeline that stretches from pages 10 to 11. Key elements of the timeline are as follows:

  • 33CE – Sowing begins
  • Sower: Jesus
  • Fine seed is sown: Anointing with holy spirit
  • The field: The world of mankind
  • Enemy: The devil
  • Men were sleeping: death of the apostles
  • Wheat: Anointed Christians
  • Weeds: Imitation Christians
  • 1914 – Harvest begins
  • Slaves/reapers: Angels
  • Weedlike Christians are separated from the anointed “sons of the kingdom”
  • 1919 – Gathering into the storehouse, Anointed Christians are gathered into the restored congregation
  • Shining brightly: Shortly before Armageddon, the remaining faithful anointed ones are gathered to the heavens
  • Armageddon: At Armageddon, the weeds are pitched into the fire

It seems the Society is using the wheat and the weeds parable in this magazine as a useful replacement to fill the vacuum left by the previous understanding of the faithful slave “prophecy.” The illustration has been drafted in to build a makeshift scriptural bridge between the organization’s history and the outset of the Christian congregation in 33CE.

Another scripture that is referenced is Malachi 3:1-4, already associated in the minds of Witnesses as discussing Christ’s visit to his “spiritual temple” at the end of the First World War. The second study article adjusts this understanding by explaining that Christ visited the organization (invisibly, of course) in 1914 after the weeds (imitation Christians) had been allowed to grow for centuries among the wheat (anointed Christians). So, what position, if any, did Russell occupy when Christ visited in 1914?

“During the decades leading up to 1914, C. T. Russell and his close associates did a work like that of John the Baptizer. That vital work involved restoring Bible truths. The Bible Students taught the true meaning of Christ’s ransom sacrifice, exposed the hellfire lie, and proclaimed the coming end of the Gentile Times.” (w13 7/15 p.11)

Having been stripped of any meaningful role in God’s purpose, C.T. Russell has received the consolation of being likened to John the Baptizer

Thus, Russell is awarded the peculiar role of “John the Baptizer” in Watchtower’s new convoluted melodrama – forging the path ahead of Christ’s inspection of the organization in 1914. However, Russell and his early organization is stripped of having any meaningful role in God’s purpose. One is left wondering, if Russell’s death in 1916 happened during the “cleansing” period, does this mean that his demise was all part of God’s plan?! Regardless, only after the 1914-1919 “inspection and cleansing period” was the organization recognized as God’s organized channel, as explained on page 19…

“From 1914 to the early part of 1919, Jesus accompanied his Father to the spiritual temple to do a much-needed inspection and cleansing work. (Mal. 3:1-4) Then, starting in 1919, it was time to begin gathering the wheat. Was it finally the time for Christ to appoint one organized channel to dispense spiritual food? Yes, indeed!” (w13 7/15 p.19)

The tumultuous period in the organization’s history between 1914 and 1919 thus becomes the focus of doctrine perhaps more than ever before. There is no longer a “seamless” transition from the time of the apostles through to today. Prior to 1914, there was NO “organized channel” on the Earth. By 1919, one had been suddenly and miraculously formed – by none other than Christ himself.

A Questionable Character

There is just one small problem with hanging so much doctrinally on this murky period in Watchtower’s history. The more we delve into historical documents, the more we realise that Watchtower cannot be proud of its activities during that time – not to mention the literature that was produced. To compensate for this, the Society must reach for its eraser and smudge out some of the less savoury details of its past. This it does with reckless abandon on page 12…

“In late 1914, some Bible Students were disheartened because they had not gone to heaven. During 1915 and 1916, opposition from outside the organization slowed down the preaching work. Worse, after Russell’s death in October 1916, opposition arose from inside the organization. Four of the seven directors of the Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society rebelled against the decision to have Brother Rutherford take the lead. They tried to cause division among the brothers, but in August 1917, they left bethel – a cleansing indeed! Also, some Bible Students gave in to fear of man. Still, as a whole they willingly responded to Jesus’ cleansing work and made the needed changes. Hence, Jesus judged them to be true Christian wheat, but he rejected all imitation Christians, including all those found within the churches of Christendom. (Mal. 3:5; 2 Tim. 2:19)” (w13 7/15 p.12 par.8)

To those who are even remotely familiar with organizational events between 1914 and 1919, the above depiction of the Society’s exploits during that period is flattering at best and heavily revisionist at worst. For example, there is more to the story of the “four directors” than is told above. Note the following words from page 9 of the booklet “Light After Darkness” published by opponents of Brother Rutherford in September 1917…

The account of the four directors concerning their ousting from Bethel in 1917, from page 9 of the booklet “Light After Darkness”

As you can see, simply saying that the four directors left bethel does not tell the full story of what happened. The directors were threatened with forcible ejection by Rutherford, and finally left after it was negotiated for them to receive $300 dollars each rather than be turned out onto the street without a dime to their name. What crime had led to four directors of the Watch Tower Society being treated in this way? They had dared to object to Rutherford effectively tearing up C.T. Russell’s will, which stipulated that power should be shared evenly between Watchtower’s board of directors.

Writer and Watchtower historian, Rud Persson

In a spectacular grab for power following Russell’s death in late 1916, Rutherford used his legal knowledge to enact bylaws in early 1917 that would give him total control over the Society, and render the role of Society director all but meaningless. This was what the “four directors” spoke out against, and they were effectively evicted from their home, Brooklyn Bethel, for their troubles. You can read more about what really happened during those dark days in the above-quoted booklet “Light After Darkness,” which is available in PDF form by clicking here.

Rud Persson is a Swedish Watchtower historian who has copiously analyzed all available documents from this very episode in the organization’s history, and is compiling a book to summarize his research. I approached him by email with the above paragraph from this new Watchtower, and he made this comment…

“It is certainly true that four Directors opposed ‘the decision to have Brother Rutherford take the lead.’ They should do that, for it meant a complete departure from the way Russell, the then recognized ‘faithful and wise servant’, had arranged for matters after his death. It is not true that they ‘tried to cause division among the brothers’. That was not their purpose which was to rectify what was wrong. If spreading information was necessary to do this, then of course they felt that wisdom from above is first of all clean, thereafter peaceful. It was Rutherford with the aid of his yes-men who went public first, publicly blackening the four Directors and then Paul S.L. Johnson. It is true that the four directors left Bethel in August 1917, on August 8 to be specific, but that was not the end of the story.” – Rud Persson

I for one cannot wait for Rud’s book to come out, because I am sure it will shed much light on these events, and further undermine Watchtower’s astonishingly misplaced trust and confidence in the character of “Judge” Rutherford, not to mention this highly questionable and well-documented period in the organization’s early history.

Documented evidence shows Rutherford to have been a ruthless bigoted bully rather than a clean-cut figurehead for the fledgling Watch Tower Society

As previously mentioned on this website, during his presidency Rutherford distinguished himself as a bully and a tyrant. He allowed an atmosphere of alcoholism to permeate Bethel, and used abusive and demeaning language to intimidate and belittle any who fell short of his standards. He also lived in luxury at a time of national austerity, while many of his co-workers at Bethel lived in squalid conditions.

All of this was documented during the Olin Moyle libel lawsuit in the early 1940s, which Rutherford lost. A copy of Moyle’s resignation letter which sparked the lawsuit is available to read on this link. It gives an astonishing glimpse into what life was like in Bethel under Rutherford’s presidency, and casts serious doubt over whether Christ could really have supported such a man as custodian over his organization.

It may be that you, the reader, are so determined to think of Rutherford as a good man that you will not accept information unless it is within the Society’s own literature – even if it is documented information from a lawsuit. If that is the case, I would urge you to read my article on racism in Watchtower literature during both Russell and Rutherford’s presidency. Some of the bigoted statements made by Rutherford and his writers in the Society’s own publications defy belief, and should leave you beyond any doubt of Rutherford’s questionable character.

Despite all this, the Watch Tower Society of the 21st Century insists on ascribing Rutherford with a prominent role in the fulfilment of bible prophecy – one of the very first members of the faithful and discreet slave! Even so, it is perhaps noteworthy that Rutherford’s name is only mentioned once in all of the four study articles – and that is in the quote reproduced above. I feel this may be telling. Watchtower wants you, the reader, to focus on the date, 1919, rather than the bigoted bully behind it.

A tenuous link

Witnesses will be familiar with the Governing Body‘s constant attempts to draw parallels between themselves and Christ’s First Century apostles. The third study article, “Feeding Many Through the Hands of a Few” represents yet another example of this.

The magazine suggests that Christ’s miraculous feeding of the five thousand supports the Governing Body arrangement

The opening paragraphs remind the reader of Christ’s miracle where he fed the five thousand using just a few loaves and fishes, with his disciples distributing the miraculously produced food. (Matt 14:14-21) The writer then expands on this by explaining that spiritual feeding was of more importance to Christ than providing physical food, and it was for this reason that Christ chose his apostles.

We are then reminded in paragraph 9 of an incident in the book of Acts where a physical food shortage arose among the early Christians. The apostles sprung into action to appoint responsible brothers to ensure that food was being distributed evenly. So far the reader is thinking “Yes, but these were Christ’s apostles. There is no mention in Acts of a Governing Body.” But it doesn’t take long (paragraph 10, in fact) for the writer to make the connection…

“By 49 CE, the surviving apostles had been joined by certain other qualified elders. (Read Acts 15:1,2.) ‘The apostles and older men in Jerusalem’ served as a governing body. As the Head of the congregation, Christ used this small group of qualified men to settle doctrinal issues and to oversee and direct the preaching and teaching of the Kingdom good news.-Acts 15:6-29; 21:17-19; Col. 1:18.” (w13 7/15 p.17)

The above statement makes an unfounded assumption. It implies that, once the circumcision issue arose, the apostles were permanently “joined” by the “older men” in the making of any and all subsequent decisions related to the early congregation. There is absolutely no evidence of this. In the entire Bible, the phrase “apostles and older men” appears only six times – and all six times are in chapters 15 and 16 of Acts. It therefore seems that the involvement of the “older men” in this matter was a one-off “ad hoc” event that was borne from necessity and the uniqueness of the situation. To suggest that the apostles were unable to reach decisions without the older men from that point onwards is making an assertion that simply isn’t contained in the scriptures.

Once again the Governing Body holds aloft the account of the “apostles and older men” in Acts 15 and 16 as their mandate to rule unopposed

The next paragraph goes on to imply that, from this point onwards, the Apostle Paul was tasked with carrying out the orders of this newly formed “governing body.” It cites Acts 16:4,5 where Paul is described as delivering “for observance the decrees that had been decided upon by the apostles and older men who were in Jerusalem.”

Only when the reader looks up the scripture and notes its proximity to the circumcision issue in the previous chapter does he realise that, rather than being a permanent arrangement, Paul was merely passing on the instructions related to this particular matter. But the way the Society quotes the scriptures suggests to the reader that this was an ongoing permanent “arrangement,” and that Paul was subservient to the “apostles and older men” from then on – which, again, is asserting something that is simply not supported by scripture. Paragraph 11 then draws the reader to the following conclusion…

“Notice that those congregations prospered as a result of their loyal cooperation with the governing body in Jerusalem. Is that not proof of Jehovah’s blessing on the arrangement by means of which his Son fed the congregations? Let us remember that spiritual prosperity is possible only with Jehovah’s rich blessing.-Prov. 10:22; 1 Cro. 3:6,7.” (w13 7/15 p.18 par.11)

And so, like an accomplished magician, the writer succeeds in duping the reader into drawing two false assumptions: (1) that there was a first century governing body, which there wasn’t (and bible writers were perfectly capable of coming up with their own term in Greek to describe such an arrangement if it existed without the Watchtower adding to the scriptures), and (2) that it was a permanent ongoing arrangement rather than a one-off way of dealing with a particular problem that arose, namely circumcision.

The next paragraph is one of the most intriguing in the magazine, but it serves a very deliberate purpose. It states…

“Thus far we have seen that Jesus followed a pattern when feeding his followers: He fed many through the hands of a few. The channel he used for spiritual feeding was clearly recognizable. After all, the apostles – the original members of the governing body – could provide visible proof of heavenly backing. ‘Through the hands of the apostles many signs and portents continued to occur among the people,’ states Acts 5:12. Hence, there was no reason for those who became Christian to wonder, ‘Who really are the ones through whom Christ is feeding his sheep?’ But by the end of the first century, the situation changed.” (w13 7/15 p.18 par.12)

The paragraphs that follow go on to describe Christianity’s slide into apostasy following the death of the apostles, but rather than allowing ourselves to be swept along by the rhetoric, the true purpose of the above paragraph must be fully recognized. The Society is now trying to make the point, which it repeats more clearly on page 21, that the faithful slave scripture COULD NOT have applied to the apostles because their authority was unmistakable due to their “signs and portents.”

The magazine twice tries to argue that the “faithful slave” could not have applied to the apostles because it was mentioned in the form of a question

Simply put, the Society now argues that, because Matthew 24:45 is written in the form of a question (i.e. “Who really is the faithful and discreet slave…?”), Jesus could not have been referring to his apostles. They say that, because it was so obvious that the apostles were in charge, such a question would be irrelevant. However, as I will argue later in this article, this reasoning is so flawed it is almost laughable.

In reality, all the Society achieves with the above paragraph is to inadvertently remind thinking Witnesses that the Governing Body really has no “visible proof” of their appointment by Christ. Sure, they have an organization that is expanding at an underwhelming annual growth rate of 1.9% (as of 2012), but it is also an organization that imposes the torturous shunning of family members and is increasingly making itself the subject of legal pressure on account of its damaging child abuse policies. The idea that the individual Governing Body members are somehow invisibly hand-picked by Christ is therefore unthinkable – so unthinkable that even the Society evades articulating this idea in print. So where does the Governing Body get its mandate from?

I wish I could answer that question by quoting a series of paragraphs in this magazine through which the Society coherently justifies the Governing Body’s new Pope-like status. Sadly, however, there is no such material to draw from. Nowhere in these study articles is it described how Governing Body members are selected, or how it can be proven that Christ has any role in this process whatsoever. Rather, the mandate for the Governing Body to rule unquestioned over nearly 8 million people apparently hinges on three scriptures:

  1. Christ’s miracle of the loaves and the fishes in Matthew 14
  2. Two chapters in Acts, namely chapters 15 and 16 (a historical narrative about the handling of the circumcision issue by the “apostles and older men”)
  3. The verses in Matthew 24 about the faithful slave – which many argue were intended purely as a parable.

Having established such a shaky foundation for justifying the present Governing Body arrangement in the first three articles, the fourth and final article is left to drive home the message that the Governing Body is to be loyally obeyed without question, because its future approval by Christ is already set in stone. This is underlined by the final words of the second paragraph, which states:

“It is vital that we recognize the faithful slave. Our spiritual health and our relationship with God depend on this channel.” – Matthew 4:4; John 17:3.

I looked up both scriptures. As you would expect, neither was remotely connected with the faithful and discreet slave.

Who really is the faithful and discreet slave?

It doesn’t take long for the final article to answer the above question, which forms its title. A box is provided at the top of page 22 that spells out the answer succinctly, as follows:

“‘The faithful and discreet slave’: A small group of brothers who are directly involved in preparing and dispensing spiritual food during Christ’s presence. Today, these anointed brothers make up the Governing Body.” (w13 7/15 p.22 box)

This answer is elaborated on in the text beneath, in paragraph 10…

“Who then is the faithful and discreet slave? In keeping with Jesus’ pattern of feeding many through the hands of a few, that slave is made up of a small group of anointed brothers who are directly involved in preparing and dispensing spiritual food during Christ’s presence. Throughout the last days, the anointed brothers who make up the faithful slave have served together at headquarters. In recent decades, that slave has been closely associated with the Governing body of Jehovah’s Witnesses. Note, however, that the word “slave” in Jesus’ illustration is singular, indicating that this is a composite slave. The decisions of the Governing Body are thus made collectively.” (w13 7/15 p.22, par.10)

Having unequivocally assumed such a lofty title, the Governing Body members probably felt that they needed to make some token show of humility. It was noted during the Annual Meeting that, in his talk, David Splane went to great lengths to “sell” the new teaching to the audience by pushing the new understanding of the domestics – now considered to be both anointed christians, and those of the great crowd.

David Splane extols the teaching of the domestics during the Annual Meeting

“And brothers, we LOVE this teaching.” Splane enthused, adding, “We LOVE this idea, because it really truly does dignify the members of the Great Crowd.” Many of us who watched those words being spoken on the slick JW.org promotional video have been left unconvinced. It seems obvious that the “faithful slave” has far more to “love” about this new teaching than the domestics do.

The issue of the domestics is given similar prominence in a section entitled “Who are the domestics?” on pages 22 and 23. A picture is shown at the top of page 23 in which Gerrit Lösch and his wife are seated at a congregation meeting. Gerrit glances inquisitively as a young child answers into the outstretched microphone. The message is unmistakeable. “We are normal, everyday brothers – just like anyone else!” Not everyone will be buying it.

A selection that has already been made

A key reason why the previous teaching regarding the faithful and discreet slave almost served its purpose (to some extent) was that it referred to events in the murky past that nobody could remember, and made assertions that few could authoritatively argue with unless they were prepared to do some research. For example, the Society argued that Jesus selected a Slave in 1919 that had already existed for centuries, and appointed it over all his “belongings.” Therefore, no matter what flaws the organization may now have, the argument could be made that the Slave Class had ALREADY received final approval from Christ – so any perceived flaws were irrelevant.

But now, the teaching is that Christ has YET to finally approve the Governing Body in its role as the composite slave. With this in mind, you would expect the Governing Body members to exercise a bit of humility, and not try to second guess the decision that Christ is due to make in the future during the Great Tribulation when he finally arrives to inspect his slave class. Instead, the Governing Body boldly makes Christ’s decision for him in advance. Note what is said on page 25…

“In view of the foregoing, what can we conclude? When Jesus comes for judgment during the great tribulation, he will find that the faithful slave has been loyally dispensing timely spiritual food to the domestics. Jesus will then delight in making the second appointment – over all his belongings.” (w13 7/15 p.25 par.18, bold mine)

I was amazed at the arrogance when reading the above words. One would think that, if they have any true Christ-like humility about them, the Governing Body would say words to the effect of “we will do our best to provide spiritual food, and if Christ is pleased with our efforts when he comes, he promises to appoint us over all his belongings.” Instead, as mentioned, the decision has evidently already been made by the Governing Body on Christ’s behalf that he WILL choose them when he comes.

The scriptures themselves indicate that the appointment over the belongings is not to be considered a foregone conclusion. One is reminded of the very next words in Matthew 24:48-51 (New World Translation)…

“But if ever that evil slave should say in his heart, ‘My master is delaying,’ and should start to beat his fellow slaves and should eat and drink with the confirmed drunkards, the master of that slave will come on a day that he does not expect and in an hour that he does not know, and will punish him with the greatest severity and will assign him his part with the hypocrites. There is where [his] weeping and the gnashing of [his] teeth will be.”

Ironically, the Society addresses this scripture by means of a box on page 24, on the page just before it makes the bold assertion that it WILL be selected. The box begins by discussing the “evil slave” and makes the following statement…

“Was Jesus foretelling that there would be an evil slave class in the last days? No. Granted, some individuals have manifested a spirit similar to that of the evil slave described by Jesus. We would call them apostates, whether they were of the anointed or of the “great crowd.” (Rev. 7:9) But such ones do not make up an evil slave class. Jesus did not say that he would appoint an evil slave. His words here are actually a warning directed to the faithful and discreet slave.” (w13 7/15 p.24 box)

And so a warning directed at the faithful and discreet slave is cunningly turned into an opportunity to lampoon apostates for “beating their fellow slaves.” Even though the box acknowledges that apostates are not the evil slave, it still leaps on the opportunity to misrepresent and stigmatize those who are guilty of nothing more than disagreeing with the teachings and practices of the Governing Body.

Meanwhile, the Governing Body neatly sidesteps Christ’s warning about the “evil slave.” An unnamed “scholar” makes a brief cameo, and is quoted as saying: “for all practical purposes [the evil slave warning] is a hypothetical condition.” (bold and brackets mine) The writer thus dismisses the entire portion of scripture, declaring further on in the box that the Governing Body “has continued to keep on the watch and to provide nourishing spiritual food.” This part of the discussion is summed up as follows…

“The anointed brothers who together serve as the faithful slave recognize that they are accountable to the Master for the way they care for his domestics. The hearfelt desire of these anointed brothers is to fulfill their responsibility loyally so that they might hear a ‘well done’ from the Master when he finally arrives.” (w13 7/15 p.24 box)

Whatever the Governing Body may profess their “heartfelt desire” to be, they cannot escape the fact that their actions and decisions have caused misery and heartache to countless thousands through their cruel insistence on unscriptural policies such as the shunning of family members.

Jesus said that his followers would be identified by the love they have among themselves (John 13:35), and yet the breaking up of families purely because somebody decides to leave his or her former religion is anything but loving. Those labelled “apostates” and slandered with hate speech merely for daring to disagree with the Governing Body have every reason to think of these men as an “evil slave,” whether such ones still consider themselves Christians or not. It is therefore difficult to fathom how the Governing Body can boldly consider Christ’s approval of their methods to be a foregone conclusion. (Matt. 7:21-23)

The 2013 Governing Body, as they appear on page 26 of the July 15th Watchtower

More questions than answers

In total there are 23 pages in the four study articles combined. And yet, for all the sleek illustrations, carefully worded paragraphs and prophetic timelines, the magazine leaves key questions regarding the organization’s new doctrines unanswered. Here are just a few…

  • What scripture supports the fact that the “inspection and cleansing work” would take Christ four and a half years (from late 1914 to early 1919)?” (p.11) – Repeatedly the magazine insists that the four and a half years between late 1914 and early 1919 was a period of “inspection and cleansing” by Christ. However, nowhere is any scripture provided to explain why Christ would need this specific length of time to achieve this purpose. Rather, it seems that events in the organization’s history have been taken as the “evidence” – and the scriptures just have to fit around them.
  • The early Bible Students were said to commit an “organizational sin” by ripping out fiercely political pages of this book

    What were the circumstances under which the early Bible Students “gave in to the fear of man?” (p.12) – This statement is found on page 12, but not elaborated on. If you have the time, I would encourage you to do research on this if you haven’t already done so. In a previous article, I explored the events surrounding the publication of the Finished Mystery, and how the Bible Students were ordered by the authorities to tear out pages 247 to 253 of the book – pages that were fiercly political and critical of America’s war effort. This compromise was deemed an “organizational sin.” However, the more you research the ludicrous statements contained in the Finished Mystery, the more you reach the conclusion that Christ would actually have praised the Bible Students for ripping out its pages rather than chastising them for it.

  • If Russell and his associates were not part of God’s channel (or even the “slave class”) then why did Christ choose only to inspect them in 1914 and not any other Christian denominations? (p.19) – To put this question another way – why would Christ “inspect” one Christian denomination rather than several, or even all of them? If there was nothing special about Russell or his associates, then why did Christ effectively set up camp at Watchtower HQ for four and a half years and “inspect” them over this period? “Cleansing” is one thing, but “inspection” is something altogether different. Inspection is something you do BEFORE you are satisfied of the nature of something. Would it not have made more sense to “inspect” multiple denominations first, choose one of them, and then “cleanse” it accordingly?
  • There is no scriptural support for the notion that authority can somehow be passed on from one generation to the next

    If all of the original 1919 members of the slave chosen by Christ are now dead, how can it be said that subsequent members of the slave were chosen? – As mentioned in a previous article, a key problem with the “new light” is the question of succession. Previously, the Governing Body claimed that they were merely the representatives of a cloud-like mass of “anointed” ones that has always existed since the time of the apostles. Now, however, they have effectively evaporated this “cloud” and insisted that their appointment came directly from Christ in 1919. But all of the 1919 board of directors are now dead and buried, so how can it be assumed that their position as “faithful slave” was passed on to their successors? The Society has roundly condemned the catholic principle of apostolic succession in their literature – including the Reasoning Book. It is one thing to suggest that Christ came and selected Rutherford and his associates in 1919 (despite the connotations of this, once you look at Rutherford’s character and what they were printing at the time). It is another thing entirely to assume that this status of “the faithful and discreet slave” was somehow passed like a baton to successive generations down through the decades since 1919 based purely on the necessity caused by people dying. No explanation is given as to how this was achieved, other than the suggestion that it “just did” – which is essentially Watchtower’s version of apostolic succession. With this new teaching, Watchtower has become more like the catholic church than it would care to admit.

  • Why can it be said with certainty that Christ’s original apostles were not at least part of the faithful and discreet slave? (p.21) – This question is posed on page 21 of the magazine, but nowhere is it satisfactorily answered. The only explanation offered is that the “faithful and discreet slave” statement by Jesus was posed in the form of a question, and therefore it couldn’t possibly have applied to the apostles since there was no doubt at all that these ones had Christ’s authority. However, the asking of a question does not necessarily imply doubt. For example, what about “rhetorical questions” where the answer is known before the question is asked? And if it was such a foregone conclusion that the apostles would live up to Christ’s expectations, then why did Jesus go to such lengths to tell Peter to “feed my little sheep” after his resurrection? (John 21:15-19) The article insists that there was “hardly a reason to ask such a question” regarding the apostles, yet recognizing the authority of the apostles as the “faithful slave” was as much a choice for early Christians as it is for Witnesses regarding the Governing Body today. This is highlighted by the fact that some early Christians deviated from the apostles’ leadership. (2 Tim 2:16-18) The Society’s reasoning is thus SO flawed that the question is effectively left unanswered.
  • It seems that working at World Headquarters in New York is a key criterion for being considered part of the Faithful Slave, even though there is no scriptural basis for this assertion

    Just what is so special about headquarters? (p.22) – According to the new explanation of the faithful slave, it seems that a key identifying feature of a composite slave member is not WHO he is, or even whether he has a heavenly hope or not. What apparently matters is WHERE he happens to work. Nowhere in Christ’s discussion of the slave does it hint that “location, location, location” would be at all important in identifying who the faithful slave is, so how can the organization be so dogmatic in insisting that “headquarters” in New York carries such relevance in making this biblical determination?

  • How can the Governing Body justify insisting that they WILL be appointed by Christ over “all of this belongings” in advance of this event? (p.25) – As discussed above, many sincere Witnesses will be left scratching their heads at the brazenness of the Governing Body in insisting they WILL be appointed by Christ over his belongings before he has even come in judgment. The decision has been effectively snatched out of Christ’s hands, and made for him.

An organization as porous as its teachings

By now you have probably reached the conclusion that most of what is discussed in the four articles of this new magazine either makes no sense at all, or was already covered at the Annual Meeting nearly six months ago – an event at which some 15,000 privileged Witnesses were treated to a glimpse of the “new light” before millions of their brothers around the world.

The Governing Body preferred to receive applause and fanfare at their Annual Meeting than go to any efforts to make sure their “new light” reached the global brotherhood simultaneously

As discussed in a previous article, it took more than a month following the Annual Meeting for news of the “new light” to be finally confirmed on the Society’s official web pages, and nearly two months for this information to be made available in languages other than English. Finally, six months after the information was divulged from a New Jersey platform, the worldwide brotherhood are finally getting to hear about this doctrine in print – a doctrine that carries profound implications regarding the authority of the Governing Body.

No longer are the Governing Body self-appointed representatives of a some obscure cloud of anointed Witnesses that has always existed in some form stretching back to the time of the apostles. They are now self-appointed representatives, not of heaven-bound Christians, but of Christ himself. They answer to no one, not even Christ whom they represent! After all, they have made his decision to appoint them over “all his belongings” for him in advance. Any meaningful evidence to support their claims is deemed irrelevant.

True, it may be that even before this announcement a good number of Witnesses considered the Governing Body to be the faithful and discreet slave, but this would only realistically have been for one (or both) of two reasons: (1) ignorance on the part of individuals regarding Watchtower doctrine, or (2) confusion as a result of the way in which the Governing Body increasingly presented themselves over many years as being synonymous with the Slave Class. The fact that the rhetoric coming down from the Society led many to predict the announcement in advance does not lessen the fact that the new teaching carries profound implications. It consolidates the authority of the Governing Body, and effectively elevates them to Pope-like status.

The leaking of this magazine and other documents proves that more thinking Witnesses are finding the courage to take action

With all this considered, perhaps we learn more from the fact that this magazine has been leaked weeks ahead of its release than from anything contained in its pages. The Watch Tower Society now seems unable to hold water both in terms of its doctrines and in keeping information confidential, as more and more information is leaked by conscientious individuals within the growing ranks of thinking Witnesses.

It is exhilarating to think that so many within the organization are waking from their indoctrination and finding the courage to take risks by getting information like this article into the hands of those who will make use of it. I only hope that this pattern continues, so that more and more true light can shine down on this quirky organization with its dubious history, shady practices and tangled teachings.







This article has been translated into: Russian | Hungarian | Italian | Romanian

A four-page PDF of unknown authorship showing “adjustments in understanding” is available on this link.

Bookmark the permalink.

143 Responses to “New light” Watchtower magazine leaked from organization weeks ahead of general release

  1. sabastious says:

    Awesome article Cedars! The Watchtower is a dysfunction of society that is enabled by it’s people. So many have defended their right to lie to, cheat, steal and abuse their own people. All in the name of “freedom of religion.” They are not a religion, they are a virtual nation who are slowly indoctrinating their citizens into a standing army. One day they will hand them guns and tell them to march on the governments of the world. Will we be ready?

  2. Yan Bibiyan says:

    Cedars, great work!

    A thingy caught my eye….the “apostles and older men” illustration above has EIGHT bearded guys talking (football :-) over scrolls.

    And the new FDS is composed of how many members?

    Coincidence? Maybe…

    • Cedars says:

      Hi Yan, thanks very much! I should probably mention that none of the images I’ve used in my article to illustrate my points are found in the magazine itself. I’ve quoted from the magazine, but not reproduced any scans – so no, there’s nothing special about that. Sorry!!

  3. CAMOKO says:

    It is not… It is posted as a subliminal picture to reside in one’s subconscience, from wich any (re)action is prepared and then performed, thus to manipulate one’s “yes” and “no”

  4. Ms Jacobs says:

    Concerned that more and more comments toward anointed will be leaving before new world begins. The memorial talk hinted at it now this magazine. F and D are all anointed not just GB.

  5. Nick says:

    As predicted the new light totally eliminates Charles Russell as having anything to do with the FDS! They need to do this of course because of his wacky teachings…but as this excellent article points out Rutherford was worse!

  6. Kurt says:

    This article might bolster the position of the governing body as leaders, excuse me, taking the lead among those who accept it at face value, but it creates two new problems.

    First thing, there is the claim that someone can not get Bible understanding alone, but must get taught from an organization that channels God. The teaching has been that the organization has been in existence since the first century and the faithful slave has been feeding people through it. With this new teaching, you have 19 centuries of people somehow coming to understanding of the Bible and becoming wheat Christians, all without a faithful slave or organization. So one could rightfully reason that if people were able to understand the Bible all that time without organizational leadership then they could certainly do so now.

    Secondly, even if one takes leave of the facts and their powers of reason enough to accept this article as being accurate, it creates another problem. Accepting that in 1919 some men were appointed as a faithful slave, they are all dead now. The current men in the governing body were not appointed then, and there is no provision for them to be appointed in some form of apostolic succession, which the Reasoning book points out is “not a Biblical teaching”. That leaves the governing body in the position of being ordinary men making unscriptural boastful claims about themselves in order to deceive people into obeying their orders.

    This corporation has painted itself into an even smaller corner with this article with no way out. It has no credibility.

    Thank you for your review and other work you have done in examining the works of the Watchtower corporation.

  7. miken says:

    This further self-assumed authority of the governing body makes the question as to whether or not their claim to appontment in 1919 is true or false an even more critical question than previously. Don Cameron in his Captives of a Concept addresses the question and beyond doubt shows the claim to be untrue. See http://captivesofaconcept.com/
    The two main prophetic publications distributed after the supposed 1919 inspection and appointment were The Finished Mystery and Millions Now Living Will Never Die, both claimed to be produced under divine direction. The prophecies of course failed, a sign of divine appointment?
    Rutherford was regarded as the ‘Faithful and Discreet Slave or Steward’ successor to Russell not a group of men at the Brooklyn bethel see the 1917 pamphlet The Parable of the Penny at http://wtarchive.svhelden.info/english/books-and-tracts/

    Rutherford himself controlled what was published and wrote a vast amount himself as well as doing radio broadcasts and grammarphone recordings together with numerous assembly and conventions talks. At the first annual meeting after Rutherford’s death in 1942 in a unanimous declaration it was stated that “instructions come to the Lord’s people on earth from the office of the president of the Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society, filled by anointed men chosen of the Lord in his organization;”
    Jehovah’s Witnesses Yearbook 1943 page 169.
    Analysis of the historical recorded facts during the Rutherford presidency and the major part of the Knorr presidency do not substantiate thelatest claims of group preparation of supposed spiritual food, however groups wre probably involved in the distribution.

  8. Mrs C says:

    Great article Cedars!! I really hope the active Witnesses will think about those seven questions.

  9. AWAKENOW says:

    Cedars – Beautiful piece of work. Just excellent. A great counter point and voice of reason to the GB’s “murky madness.”

    They are now fully qualified to be “The Man of Lawlessness” at 2 Thessalonians chapter 2, which the first century Christians condemed. In part it says:

    “However, brothers, respecting the presence of our Lord Jesus Christ… we request of you not to be quickly shaken from your reason… Let no one seduce you in any manner..” (2Thes 2:1-3)

    “He… lifts himself up over everyone who is called “god” or an object of reverence, so that he sits down in the temple of The God, publicly showing himself to be a god.” (2Thes 2:4)

    Think about it:
    - They assert that God accepts only one organized and true religion to serve him and to reveal his will, then claim that they are God’s spokesman and exclusive channel for true worship for mankind today. Thus they replace God’s will and authority with their own.
    - They assert personal salvation and a relationship with Christ depends on how mankind responds to Christ brothers, then as self appointed mediator and teacher claim they are his true brothers. Thus they replace Christ as mediator and savior.
    - They assert themselves to a superior position while inserting themselves into the center of their followers lives requiring absolute loyalty, total devotion, and unquestioning obedience. Thus they have dictated faith, obstructed salvation, and hijacked the worship of millions of people.

    “…indeed, the lawless one will be revealed, whom the Lord Jesus will do away with …because they did not accept the love of the truth…” (2Thes 2:10)

    Sadly, Jesus’s description seems to apply to them quite well: “In that way you also, outwardly indeed, appear righteous to men, but inside YOU are full of hypocrisy and lawlessness. (Matthew 23:28)

    Cedars, keep turning the screws as long as you can. Information like this and the heartfelt, loving, and insightful comments posted on this site are a treasure.

  10. musicman4283 says:

    Excellent article! I mean, WOW! I have been waiting for these retards to print some “New Light” for some time now. A person very close to me has been studying with JWs and has repeatedly been lead to believe that there haven’t been any drastic changes in doctrine. As soon as I get my hands on that PDF of the magazine I will finally be able to show this person just how ridiculous the claims of the governing body are. Hope you don’t mind, but I will probably use some of your points from this article to drive the point home. I, with your help, am on the verge of saving yet another person from this horrible organization! Thanks for all you do.

  11. miken says:

    Thus they replace Christ as mediator and savior”.

    “It is vital that we recognize the faithful slave. Our spiritual health and our relationship with God depend on this channel.” – Matthew 4:4; John 17:3.

    Note not on Jesus Christ (John 14:6). Could this be the reason why Jesus is totally missing in the illustration regarding the earthly organization and its relationship to and by the heavenly organization on page 29 of the April 15 Watchtower magazine. There is even a heirarchy of seating quality from the governing body down!

    For anyone interested the bylaws Rutherford got passed at the first annual meeting after Russell death held in Jan 1917 to gain control of the society are recorded in the court transcript of the Olin Moyle case 1527-1532 See

  12. KtotheRAD "Konrad" says:

    I can only sum up my thoughts in these simple cursory symbols which I’m sure, whether spoken or not will be shared by many both inside and outside of the organization:


  13. Magusknight1974 says:

    Well Cedars I believe the time is getting closer for us all to see the true nature of this light. Remember Satan is the Great Deceiver and we all can admit he is doing a Grand Job with this group. The first step to unified power is too eliminate the old beliefs in order to create new ones. The path for the future of this group required this new movement to take place quickly. The Roman Caesar would do this in order to focus control and power over his Empire to favor him. I always knew this day would arrive and this is fulfilling prophecy in our time. Jesus warns us of a time when people would assume power in his name. ! John Chapter 4 and verses 8-12 show that we must know our God by his attribute of Love and follow this example. I do not see how changing the power structure of this organization while still not addressing the real concerns on policy is loving in any manner. Jehovah and Jesus both are not happy with this new evolution in thought but will separate those good ones from this organization. Trust in your God with your whole heart and be like the tree that’s leaves never wither and die. If we show love and continue to help guide those blinded by false light are displaying ourselves as True Christians mentioned in the Bible. Keep fighting this organization for if they are truly protected by divine powers we are no match but if they are not they will fall in ruins. A little flair but it makes the point. Love ya all.

  14. Jane Robertson says:

    So Jesus used 12 men to feed less than 10,000 people but uses less than 10 to feed millions the logic is stretched so thin it is impossible to see. The problem with any lie is it grows and grows as you try to plug the gaps. The societies lie is now out of control and becoming more ridiculous. I can only hope that a few will see the issue with this teaching and leave never to return.

  15. TheSnarkyApologist says:

    I agree with everyone else, yes, it is a great article. BUT!!!!
    My question is this….”how can we flog the daylights out of them with it? lol…..

  16. Frank says:

    If the UN is going to turn on religion it is likely at the request of the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society.

    Type in “Jehovah’s Witnesses” into the search engine at:


    and you’ll find 147 references to the religious rights of JWs to preach.

    Then go to:


    and read the first two lines:

    “The OSCE recognizes that the United Nations Security Council bears primary responsibility for the maintenance of international peace and security. Thus, the United Nations is the OSCE’s primary partner organization.”

    Then try:


    As you will see, this is JW.org. Why does the UN “image of the Scarlet-Coloured Wild Beast even come up? The squeaky wheel gets the oil!

    How do we know WTBTS uses UN clout?


    Note theses sentiments written by the WTBTS itself:

    “Human Rights Violated
    The ability to practice religion freely is a basic human right,
    supported by the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights,
    the European Convention on Human Rights, and the Constitution of the French
    Republic. Yet the tax authority believes it has the right to use its
    power of taxation arbitrarily to restrict some religions but not others.”

    Join the dots and what do we get?

    Frank V

  17. C M says:

    Wow this article truly spoke to me I hope they are held accountable for the lies and harsh rules that have been the cause of death, heartbreak, suffering by so many. Every time the doctrine changes more and more people are “awakening’ and the fact that the Magazine was leaked ahead of time is proof that even in places where they have access to such things we find “awakened brothers”. I am going through persecution myself as my family has found out that I am learning TTATT and no longer believe this to be the one true religion and accussing me of apostasy and blaming me for their health and money issues etc. because they have all lost Jehovah’s protection according to them. I have been kicked out of the house, not for being a drug addict, not for stealing, I have done nothing wrong scripturally and yet they have gave me the ultimatum and will shun me, thanks to their WT mindset. But in time I think more and more will see what is really going on. And the they will see how wrong they were for kicking their children out of their homes, letting their loved ones die for not recieving a blood ( or bone marrow transplant ) transfusion, for shunning people and chosing the org. over them, for teaching false doctrines,etc. No 8 men can have all that power the time is tickin let us count the hours and until then the world and our loved ones are theirs.

    C M

  18. Frank says:

    “With 57 States from Europe, Central Asia and North America, the OSCE is the world’s largest regional security organization. It offers a forum for political negotiations and decision-making in the fields of early warning, conflict prevention, crisis management and post-conflict rehabilitation, and puts the political will of its participating States into practice through its unique network of field missions.

    “The OSCE has a comprehensive approach to security that encompasses politico-military, economic and environmental, and human aspects. It therefore addresses a wide range of security-related concerns, including arms control, confidence- and security-building measures, human rights, national minorities, democratization, policing strategies, counter-terrorism and economic and environmental activities.

    “All 57 participating States enjoy equal status, and decisions are taken by consensus on a politically, but not legally binding basis.”

    Notice here: “(The OSCE) offers a forum for POLITICAL negotiations…”


    “…comprehensive approach to security that encompasses POLITICO-MILITARY…”

    “…taken by consensus on a POLITICALLY…”

    Frank V

  19. Frank says:

    Here’s just one document containing a SUBMISSION to this ‘politico-military’ organisation for enforced recognition of “freedom of religion”:


    The fact seems that the “European Association of Jehovah’s Christian Witnesses” takes on the appearance of a ‘political arm’ of God’s Organisation!

    I’m confused. Where does James 4:4 fit in with this scenario? If I made submission to a political organisation, wouldn’t I disfellowshipped?

    Frank V

  20. slavenomore says:

    well written and great points throughout especially at the end. Hopefully more will see the lunacy of the men behind the curtain and leave them behind to live the rest of their lives in true freedom. Fine work cedars! I have enjoyed all your articles thus far and anticpate your future posts. Cheers!

  21. Issac says:

    Wonderful. From past 3 months I am meeting 4 jw people ( & indirectly putting a lot of doubt in there mind about wt , my source is 4jehovah.org & jwfacts.com and now jw servey) . I just want to cash this movement (of new light) to bring them in TRUE LIGHT (JESUS) . So just give some tips. I want to tell, WT use New Light just for there advantage. So can I make some indiect predections in front of them, that ur organisation may soon change something which is actually logical but for you people it is new light. And after 15 days when they see the magzine they will remember my words and think either I am demon or they are fool. They just surf jw.org. Other websites are tools of devil 4 them. Give me some logical reason for these changes so that I can say it is logical nothing spritual and they may realize Oo. Man. From past 1 month my family is praying for there delevrance . When I saw this I said, wow nice oppertunity.
    English is not my mothertoung so correct spellings and grammers.
    I just want those people out from WT

  22. Lise says:

    Thank you for this information. Sometimes I think back to my days in school being taught history if we could all learn about a religions past before we were taught the beliefs would we even have joined. I wished my family would have investigated first instead of being sucked in with all the so called love. I was raised in it took me about ten years after walking away coldturkey to actually start realizing that I could look up the history. The power of getting over the fear I supose and just the ingrained behavior.

  23. This article is brilliantly researched and expertly written. Thank you for your efforts to get the truth out there. Matthew.

  24. Cedars says:

    Thanks for the kind comments everyone!

    It might be worth mentioning that I’ve made an adjustment to the account of the four directors. Rud Persson has been in touch again and informed me that rather than being kicked out there was more of a “negotiated withdrawal.”

    The account of attendants being posted to the doors to stop people re-entering applied to the ejection of a different Rutherford dissident – Paul Johnson, who wasn’t a director. Johnson left the building to run some errands and returned to find the doors locked and his belongings out on the street.

    I’ve modified the article accordingly and included the actual quote from the 1917 book “Light After Darkness” describing the circumstances of the directors’ ejection in more detail. As I say in the article, I can’t wait for Persson’s book to come out and explain everything, because “Light After Darkness” is a little topsy-turvy to read in that it doesn’t describe everything in chronological order but keeps going backwards and forwards.

  25. BeenMislead says:

    Thank you Cedars for all your work in preparing this article!!

    I have been waiting for the GB’s explanation of their so called new light of Matthew 24:45-47 in writing. And the fact that you received a copy of it three weeks ahead of time shows that many are waking up to the mind control of the organization perhaps even at headquarters.

  26. Bilbo Baggins says:

    The JW’s as a standing army? Dude I want some of what you’re smoking.

  27. JimmyCFlannigan says:

    Great article Cedars, was wondering when the GB would get around to publishing their reasoning behind this new light.

    Would be great to think this nonsense will stir up some serious dissent in Kingdom Halls around the globe but I think we know that’s probably not about to happen.

  28. Jowitness says:

    well played sir. Already posted this to reddit.com/r/exjw

  29. Frank says:

    Have a look at the New World Translation version of Philippians 1:7:

    “(Philippians 1:7) 7 It is altogether right for me to think this regarding all of YOU, on account of my having YOU in my heart, all of YOU being sharers with me in the undeserved kindness, both in my [prison] bonds and in the defending and legally establishing of the good news.”

    Now go to:

    bible.cc/philippians/1-7.htm and try to find the word “legal” in any of these other Bible translations:

    Where is the word “legal” here?

    On the same web page a scholar states:

    “And in the defence – Greek: apology. He is probably referring to the time when he made his defense before Nero, and vindicated himself from the charges which had been brought against him; see the notes at 2 Timothy 4:16. Perhaps he means here, that on that occasion he was abandoned by those who should have stood by him, but that the Philippians showed him all the attention which they could. It is not impossible that they may have sent some of their number to sympathize with him in his trials, and to assure him of the unabated confidence of the church.

    And confirmation of the gospel – In my efforts to defend the gospel, and to make it known; see Philippians 1:17. The allusion is probably to the fact that, in all his efforts to defend the gospel, he had been sure of their sympathy and cooperation. Perhaps he refers to some assistance which he had derived from them in this cause, which is now to us unknown.”

    Both the Emphatic Diaglott and the Greek Interlinear (published by the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society) does not have the original language inequivalent of “legal” in them at Philippians 1:7.

    Given that Paul here seems to be paralleling 1 Peter 3:15, where then is the BIBLICAL reasoning that governmental authorities (political involvement) would be engaged to help spread the Good News (OSCE and indirectly the UN)?

    Frank V

  30. Cedars says:

    I’ve decided to make a small update to my article under the heading “A selection that has already been made”

    One of the paragraphs about the “evil slave” now reads as follows…

    Meanwhile, the Governing Body neatly sidesteps Christ’s warning about the “evil slave.” An unnamed “scholar” makes a brief cameo, and is quoted as saying: “for all practical purposes [the evil slave warning] is a hypothetical condition.” (bold and brackets mine) The writer thus dismisses the entire portion of scripture, declaring further on in the box that the Governing Body “has continued to keep on the watch and to provide nourishing spiritual food.”

    …I feel it’s important to note that the word “hypothetical” is used to describe the part of the scripture about the evil slave. It’s shocking that they can pull an unnamed scholar out of the woodwork when it suits them to dismiss a scripture as irrelevant, but everything else must be taken literally.


  31. brian says:

    good job cedars

  32. ashley says:

    i thoroughly enjoyed your article. i read it in one sitting and saved the links to read later.

    probably spent 5 hours on it and related research.

    good job.
    good food at the proper time. :)

    Been following this story line a while, and was waiting for them to make this claim…
    your article made me want to publish some articles i’ve written about this whole JW situation we find on our hands…

    anyway…i noticed in one link…in the article about the “Harvest Siftings” in the section entitled “Let there Be Light”


    it quotes Isaiah 53:17…i looked it up, and that book ends on 12? wtf ? just a typo?

    anyway..wish i had something deeper to say.

    • ashley says:

      guess i’ll reply on my own comment…just found out that is a “typo” ha interesting…it was 54:17

      which reads “.17

      Any weapon whatever that will be formed against you will have no success, and any tongue at all that will rise up against you in the judgment you will condemn. This is the hereditary possession of the servants of Jehovah, and their righteousness is from me,” is the utterance of Jehovah.

      this makes me think of the Candice case…guess since they lost, that should make a statement against there “hereditary possession” of being the FDS?

  33. Alec Holmes says:

    Thanks a lot Cedars!

    I don’t think I’ll ever get over the fact that they are trying to say the slave was appointed in 1919 when the president of the WT always had the last say in what went in the publications and there wasn’t anything remotely close to what the GB is supposed to be today.

    But then again, most JWs don’t realize that the WT is a corporation and that the GB really are a board of directors.

  34. A caption beneath a photo of WT headquarters reads, “t seems that working at World Headquarters in New York is a key criteria for being considered part of the Faithful Slave, even though there is no scriptural basis for this assertion” The word “criteria” is plural. It should be “a key criterion.”

    Just being picky. Thanks for all the info.

  35. KtotheRAD "Konrad" says:

    @ sabastious ~ “One day they will hand them guns and tell them to march on the governments of the world. Will we be ready?”
    It is my understanding as has been posted on topix and elsewhere that Elders have been approved to carry weapons now in fear of reprisal from DF’d ones and others they have brutalised in their capacity…Fear and specifically fear of Man and the need for self defense is the prominant indication of the absence of Jehovah’s Spirit! The initial need for austerity measures and the heavy handed , micro managed control over people and their lives and affairs with the unscriptural judicial committee arrangment not only showed a blasphemous lack of faith in God’s ability to control the congregation but created the very opposing Army they now face and fear!
    (Excuse the lack of available spell check)

    • JBob says:

      That was a news item on local tv that pastors are now authorized to enforce security and that security officers may carry, but most religions are reluctant to comment as houses of worship are still viewed as “welcoming” places.

      But, interesting, huh–fear of reprisal? So, they know they’re making avowed enemies and hostiles? Yet carry-on in the so-called name of Jehovah–abusing kids, etc.

      This is going to be a stream of consciousness tonight–bear with me–

      Speaking of abused kids, has anyone noticed that full-time “servants” in the Watchtower movement have a disdain and loathing of children as career interruptus? They’ll smile and pet kids on the head, but are ill-at-ease relating to children unless they’re becoming perfect little JW children. So, point, is it any wonder that this sort of child-hating atmosphere has led to pedophiles being tolerated? and, children being beaten to death, or near?

      So, now for a bit of logic–

      Jesus–well, Christ, as I’ve said it before, came back in 1914 (or was it 1918?) to cleanse the temple sanctuary. Interjection point, some may want to scan Google for a little phrase known in Adventist movement as “investigative judgement”. Now, continuing, so, Jesus arrives in 1918 and begins cleaning house–a la the Temple arrival–but ignores the Christmas tree at Bethel, the Crosses and Masonic emblems embossed onto the literature, and their failure to disfellowship for immorality and drunken behavior at birthday parties [even at Bethel]. Apparently, Jesus gets a celestial (theocratic) vacuum cleaner and really decides to do a little Parousia house-cleaning between 1919 and 1923. Apparently, a divine son-of-god can’t do 1,000 years work in 4 years or less?

      What is a possibility regarding this “new light” is that it sets the stage for the Watchtower-GB, if they so choose, to unravel the steps Rutherford/Knorr/Franz took toward further isolating Jehovah’s Witnesses from mainstream Christianity–banishing crosses, banishing Christmas and holidays, blood transfusions, flag saluting, etc. If the sanctuary was clean-as-a-whistle by 1919, why would there be a need to abandon “Babylonian practices and beliefs”? Their Adventist cousins didn’t abandon the Cross, but did cling to soul-sleep.

      But, realistically, this represents a bold-move by the hardliners to rally the wagons in a last-stand to shore-up the 1914 AD belief and renew a claim to Messianic appointment. In a prior post I mentioned how the GB uses this distorted claim that Russell predicted 1914 AD, or the unfolding events of 1914 AD in retrospect, as a claim of divine-right of sovereignty instead of the traditional apostolic succession used by mainstream churches, even Protestant denominations without any line of succession will claim apostolic succession via the words of the Apostles in scripture. The Watchtower’s GB left this behind long-ago by claiming an extra-authority which supersedes scripture [Watchtower pub prose always trumps speakers and Word of God].

      What’s a hardliner vs a softie, or liberal/progressive JW and GB member? Hard liners still cling to the “just around the corner” fan the flames of anticipation–hard core adventism/millennialism; their approach to research is to scan through former JW publications, where passages have not been superseded, to make points on current views or to restore former views. Progressives approach research as a journey for facts and ignore what the past tradition may have erroneously put forward; this research often leads to a view that avoids a focus on end-times and puts a greater focus on Christian living. Hardliners believe every thing must be sacrificed to serve the Watchtower, while progressives have a balanced worship-life view where worship coexists with personal drives and talent-development.

      In short, the bad guys seem to be winning and taking over the Writing and Teaching department and the GB. We can expect more bizarre statements and teachings, soon. Also, a harsher (can be any worse?) stance toward those who disagree with GB–good old-fashioned 1980′s style witch-hunts?

  36. Take a look at Luk.14 :7 -11 about what GB have done since 1919.

  37. JBob says:

    Not any more Ms. Jacobs–not any more…

    Remember, if the GB says the grass is blue, and the sky is green, and the sun is black–thus saith the GB.

  38. Julia Orwell says:

    Cedars, this is a great article! This whole WT is twisting my brain into knots trying to figure out their reasoning, and yes, it leaves so many more questions unanswered.

    The articles seem to be deliberately designed to be confusing, hence the reason my mind seems to keep sliding around the ideas rather than grasp them. I’m so grateful to you that you have such a clear head for these things because I look at something like this and just beat a mental retreat!

    So thanks for taking the time to expose the subtexts.

  39. Elizheva Lau says:

    I think I read this in one of the Bible Students’ book:

    Christ’s miracle of the loaves and fishes is held aloft as a foregleam of his intentions to appoint only a small group of men over the spiritual feeding work.

  40. 70wksofyrs says:

    Cedars, very good so far, I must admit I am still not finished, however I would like to comment on what I have read…………

    Most of your direct quotes from the watchtower July 2013, refer to the faithful slave. Your quotes miss out the word…. discreet ….

    I find this quite interesting, did the quotes not contain the word …discreet…
    Or…. Did you consciously misquote the watchtower………?

    The Governing Body do however seem aloft, and proud not ………discreet… in any way shape or form, they are in fact the faithful indiscreet slave, would you not agree?

    I will continue, where I left off now

    Warm regards

    • Cedars says:

      Hello 70wks – I have quoted the scanned copy as closely as possible. I’m not sure why you would reach the conclusion that I have “consciously misquoted” the watchtower, just because the word “discreet” is missing in places? If I type “faithful slave” into Watchtower Library, it returns 298 results for that phrase. Isn’t it therefore more likely that they have abbreviated the phrase so that the magazine flows more easily?

  41. 70wksofyrs says:

    Fair comment you make about 298 times. I did the search also; my version brings up 303 times. The actual Bible only has the phrase twice, both in Mathew. Very interesting comment…….

    Maybe the GB don’t know they are not being discreet… and are blatantly puffed up in their own self-appointed high place.

    I think it is quite ironic then that the writers have dropped the word discreet. When I looked through the searches….

    1990-1999 = 63 times
    2000-2009 = 67 times

    Compared with previous years these two figures are more than double most time periods.

    Hence, I still have faith that Jehovah reveals loving kinds ones to one another and exposes cruel and evil ones. I do not wish to offend the many who are so badly suffering today, if I could remove their suffering I would.

    Your site has helped me, to stay motivated and zealous to read the Bible

    Cedars, keep on exposing the bad, it’s really refreshing.

    Warm regards

  42. KtotheRAD "Konrad" says:

    One thing I would like everyone to make a specific and careful note of if they haven’t already is this passage:

    “Was Jesus foretelling that there would be an evil slave class in the last days? No. Granted, some individuals have manifested a spirit similar to that of the evil slave described by Jesus. We would call them apostates, whether they were of the anointed or of the “great crowd.” (Rev. 7:9) But such ones do not make up an evil slave class. Jesus did not say that he would appoint an evil slave. His words here are actually a warning directed to the faithful and discreet slave.” (w13 7/15 p.24 box)

    This is extremely significant and revealing for many reasons but the most important to us are these:
    (1) By denying that they are the Evil Slave and that there now even is an Evil Slave class, they are in fact confessing to being that very Evil Slave! They had to do something with them so they made them disappear…in their imaginations! “Loose lips sink Ships” and scripturally, “In many words there is transgression”
    (2) They have reached a point where they have finally been forced to respond to charges by publicly explaining themselves…Anyone who knows anything about Human Behaviour knows that this, beginning to explain oneself or account is a demonstration of capitulation and they have effectively gone belly up at this point! At least demonstrably speaking since the game was lost some time agoFrom here forward as Snarky said, “Flog them” as the opportunity for the death lunges are hither from the one above and those below as they will forever be explaining their criminal conduct and those of their worldwide minions and legal jackals, past and present! They have “Jumped the Shark” as it were…and there will never be another excuse for claiming to believe their own dogmatic hype about “anointing” or “spirit appointment” to save them from accountability for their actions and decisions…

  43. messenger4truth says:

    Another key factor by their changing of the 1918 inspection.
    Is the two witnesses teaching in Revelation which they say were the ‘Elijah and Moses’ of Rutherford and co being imprisoned.
    Then released. Therefore, these amendments they have made in April addition; over turns this, surely?
    However, reading Revelation on the two witnesses who prophecy and are killed. Then are taken up into heaven! It is very clear to any sensible reader this happens after the “disgusting thing” enters the holy place!? So it impossible Rutherford and co fulfilled this. As this is to occur in the future.

  44. Anonymous says:

    well at least we wont have to study the Revelation book again, unless they bring out an updated version to torture us again.

  45. KtotheRAD "Konrad" says:

    “well at least we wont have to study the Revelation book again, unless they bring out an updated version to torture us again.” ~Ironic that you would say that as I am sitting in a building right now and there is a JW outside with a table setup and among the books is the Revelation Climax book!
    It’s interesting to note that by the logic of the GB that Jesus was “only asking” with regard to the “Evil Slave” but was not he also only asking the same question regarding the “Faithful and Discrete Slave” as well? so why does one exist but not the other conveniently?
    It seems apparent that the turning over of “his belongings” is something that is yet to take place as a reward and that the “Faithful” ones are the few Elders and Overseers who are loyal to Jehovah’s laws and standards according to their Bible trained consciences as well as “Discrete” enough to not be jaded, fooled or otherwise drawn into illegal or immoral activities at the “commands of Men” irrespective of whether they come from the congregation, Elder Body or Watchtower Society!
    Any of us who are blessed enough to be permitted to survive into a new world would be prvileged to live under the spiritual oversight of such loyally tested “princes”…

  46. Julia Orwell says:

    I’m currently listening to a Rutherford talk from 1940 and it’s pretty cracked. A lot of it is regurgitated today, but Rutherford makes these sweeping great statements with no evidence at all to support them!
    Mind you, he’s a damn good speaker. Never heard anything like it a the KH. His fluency is second to none, his modulation and emphasis really capture the attention- I can see why he was such a successful preacher. Love him or hate him, he was a powerful speaker.
    Pity he spoke garbage…

  47. Julia Orwell says:

    Sorry, that was totally off-topic. I mean to contextualise it somehow…he’s still revered although now Russell has been stripped of his role as founder. Rutherford was presumptuous, and his organisation is still…

  48. Wakeupwitness says:

    What’s really sad is most JW’s will just skim over this “new light” and not even flinch. The “truth” will always be “the truth” no matter what. But, hopefully this new change many will wake up to the fact that the whole organization and belief is a total sham and a fraud. It’s truly sad that these folks are gonna be this gullible to fall for this change. Heck, Ray Charles can see that the Governing body is stringing them along.

  49. Eugene says:

    That proov that the end of this system of things is near

  50. Eugene says:

    this teachings is accurate and from the Bible. All single personnes can see il when examing the Bible.

  51. Shadows says:

    Just looking for a clarification.

    Is this article suggesting that there were NO anointed ones in the first century and that the 144,000 would begin to be chosen only in our modern day? Or are they just saying NO ‘Faithful Slave’ until modern day?

    The WT has to make some change in this regard. I always thought they would change the 144,000 to ‘figurative’ myself but this would also work for them saying that NO faithful Christians in the past 2,000 years were of the anointed.


    • Cedars says:

      Thanks Shadows. The new light suggests that the FDS only existed from 1919 onwards. Prior to that, stretching back to Pentecost, there were spirit anointed Christians – but these weren’t part of the FDS according to the new understanding.

  52. Keith Walker says:

    Great article, Cedars. I spoke with two JW elders just yesterday who informed me that the whole of the Great Crowd is the FDS and that the Governing body is just the figure head. I can’t wait to talk to them about this issue again.

    I asked them a question about the FDS and their relation to the great crowd. The conversation went like this.

    KW: Since we’re off topic anyway, let me ask another question about something you said about the two different groups.

    JW3: You mean the anointed and the great crowd.

    KW: Yeah, those guys. JW1, you said last week that the only kind of Christians who existed in the first century are the anointed correct?

    JW1: That is correct.

    KW: You also said today that their job is to feed the household of faith, the other sheep or the great crowd. Did I get that right?

    JW1: Yes, that is what I said.

    KW: Here is what I don’t understand. If the anointed have been in existence since the first century and their job is to dispense food to the great crowd, yet the great crowd did not come onto the scene until the early 20th century, then who were they feeding for 1900 years?

    JW1: There is a lot you don’t understand.

    KW: Clearly.

    [external links removed per site policy]

    I really look forward to seeing how this is going to be fleshed out.

  53. Shadows says:

    Thanks Cedars.

    Do they still believe that ALL 1st century Christians were of the anointed class?

    ‘Cause that always blew the ’144,000 is literal’ argument out of the water for me.

  54. Willows says:

    For the Governing Body to be the Faithful and Discreet Slave now.
    One has to ask who appointed all the anointed ones on earth, [Christ's brothers] the Faithful and Discreet Slave in the first place before this change?

  55. Willows says:

    Most people in business know the term Governing Body as synopsis with a corporation. The term Governing Body has no basis in Christianity. The Watchtower have used this term in relation to their organization. It is a corporation term not a scriptural term used by Christ. Scripturally it has the connotation of an overlord.

  56. RR says:

    The Watchtower Study article is up for downloading

  57. Marcian says:

    Yes, it’s really strange how they changed this doctrine , but it was heading that way . I often thought that the “org” was adopting ideas from other cults . While “brazen” as it sounds some of the new light they have so demonstrated in the past seems rather un biblical interrelation of scripture like Catholics use in reference to Peter as the first Pope “I also say to you that you are Peter, and upon this rock I will build My church; and the gates of Hades will not overpower it. King James Bible (Cambridge Ed.) . Now The JWs say that Peter and the Rock have no relation ; Matthew 24:45-47) 45 “Who really is the faithful and discreet slave whom his master appointed over his domestics, to give them their food at the proper time? 46 Happy is that slave if his master on arriving finds him doing so. 47 Truly I say to YOU, He will appoint him over all his belongings.
    Thousands of readers of Pastor Russell’s writings believe that he filled the office of ‘that faithful and wise servant,’ and that his great work was giving to the household of faith meat in due season. His modesty and humility precluded him from openly claiming this title, but he admitted as much in private conversation, (Watchtower Dec. 1, 1916, p. 357). There is much fallacy here . If you throw in Jesus’s parable of the “evil servant” a warning to the Watchtower : Matthew 24:48But suppose that servant is wicked and says to himself,‘My master is staying away a long time,’ 49and he then begins to beat his fellow servants and to eat and drink with drunkards. 50The master of that servant will come on a day when he does not expect him and at an hour he is not aware of. 51He will cut him to pieces and assign him a place with the hypocrites, where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth.

  58. Jasper Santiago says:

    I have seen articles written against JWs and the Watchtower but I have never seen as objective, insightful, and classy as the arguments shown in this page. Why focus too much on the FDS and set aside the role of our Lord Jesus Christ who is the head of the Congregation? The GB, while they are now leading the publishing of spiritual-related publications, cannot assume a role that directly or indirectly conflicts with the Christ as mediator between God and man. After reading through the new articles, my impression is that the Governing Body has an authority over the Great Crowd, even way above the annointed ones or those with heavenly calling? (Oh, open our ears and minds please.)

    With internet access to loads of information, I am beginning to surmise that more and more JWs are having doubts about some very key WT teachings. Problem is they cannot just freely express it for fears of being disciplined, shunned and outcast.

    May Jehovah God and our Lord Jesus Christ provide the much needed light for us to see what the TRUE light is.

  59. Elizheva Lau says:

    I agree with Willows’ comment about the term “Governing Body.” It reminds me too much of the term “Governing Board,” which is used in corporate America.

  60. Issac says:

    Now This magazine is out. While reading it’s 1st chapter q. No. 6 =>
    What will signal the beginning of the great tribulation?
    Read following ” when the Roman army (“the disgusting thing”) attacked Jerusalem and its temple (a place holy in the eyes of the Jews). In the larger fulfillment, the “standing” will occur when the United Nations (the modern-day “disgusting thing”) attacks Christendom (which is holy in the eyes of nominal Christians) “, So in that case many time, many group stood in holy places of other religions and destroyed them. I am not able to express my self in English (not my native language) but I hope you all understand. Please find more questions so we can ask answers for those illogical explanations from JW. It may open there eyes.

  61. BeenMislead says:

    This is a quote from the Watch Tower article on page 12:

    “To Whom the Work Is Entrusted, a pamphlet published in 1919, urged all anointed Christians to preach from house to house. It stated: “The work appears stupendous, but it is the Lord’s, and in his strength we will perform it. You have the privilege of sharing in it.” What was the response? From that time onward, reported The Watch Tower in 1922, the Bible Students stepped up their preaching activities.”

    But in the words of Paul Harvey “What’s the rest of the story?”

    Why did they step up their preaching activities? Because Rutherford was saying “Millions now living will never die” and that the End of this system of things was coming in 1925.

    I wonder why they did not mention that?

  62. KtotheRAD "Konrad" says:

    I was approached by some witnesses who were out in service a few days ago and I was absolutely floored when the man who approached me refused to accept the reality of the Indictments, $3 Billion lawsuit and criminal proceedings taking place in Australia right now against the Governing Body. It’s as if he were in absolute and complete denial!
    At first I thought maybe he just didn’t know and then it ocurred to me that he simply refused to accept the reality. After I referred him to Jwleaks.org to view the documents his whole disposition changed and I knew that he already knew.
    I was very angry and upset at first that he was calling me a liar and then I was even angrier at him for being so stupid and finally it ocurred to me that he like so many millions of JW’s simply aren’t prepared to accept the reality of what they are dealing with as they perceive it as too painful and a failure of God, as if there could be, instead of the fulfillment of prophecy that it truly is…

    Here is however some links to more Watchtower legal failures that were conveniently swept under the rug in deference to the “shining and glorious victories that forever changed the world for the betterment of all mankind!” (- :


  63. KtotheRAD "Konrad" says:

    a link to some…

  64. issac says:

    They said on page 14
    Paragraph 7: [4] From 1910 to 1914, the Bible Students distributed nearly 4,000,000 books and over 200,000,000 tracts and pamphlets.
    Now how true is that? Was that much people were there at that time?

    • Magusknight1974 says:

      I agree the numbers seem a little more than practical over the years. The count is always higher because they do not take into account when people throw them away and are given another one later. I find them at yard sales and thrift shops as I have traveled through various areas. Reviewing most of the literature prior to the recent decade seems to me outdated or obsolete. Complicated, bias, racist, misunderstood, unrealistic, and more adjectives that I could list. It bothers me that this finish line on this race has constantly been continued. When do the millions of confused followers of this way of thought wake up to its treachery. I love Jehovah and Jesus just fine without this organization dictating my life for me. I have not been abandoned by either of these great leaders. So why do the others believe in the fear of being alone when our Great Creator and his wonderful Son Jesus are always present and available to us all. I do not need scripture for comfort but it does comfort me when needed. My comfort is from having a personal relationship with both Jehovah and Jesus which does not allow other earthly men or women to decide my fate. Some individuals do need special attention and guidance down the path of understanding but credit is always due to our true Masters. Yes by definition I am polytheistic (more than one God) because they both are my God. Jehovah the Almighty God and Jesus(Son) God have great abilities which by definition makes them Gods. I do respect others opinions but 1 John 4:8-12 informs me of my command to love one another as I love you. All the details in the world cannot defile this basic command. So I love all good and bad people as I am commanded too in order to understand the love my Creator has for me. Give Love & Stop Hate is the best command ever. P.S. Jehovah and Jesus will both save our brothers and sisters from this organization so we all must be patient and assist one another with love.

  65. Anonymous says:

    Has everybody heard the latest Jehovah’s Witness joke:

    The JW’s were the first on the scene (according to them) as per usual to deliver disaster aid at the Boston Marathon bombing…but only to “Their fellow believers”

    They are their own punchline!

    • Magusknight1974 says:

      I only watched as Emergency Workers assisted and many others were asked to leave the area. As all religious organizations may have aided in their own way this would be idolatry in form to state such credit as being the first. Jehovah loves all his creation not just a few so by doing this is bringing shame upon themselves.

  66. Anonymous says:

    “As all religious organizations may have aided in their own way this would be idolatry in form to state such credit as being the first” ~ Well it is only going around on JWN and the Blogs and so far not official but what is stated in the magazines in the past is how The Society brags about their alleged “relief work” at disasters such as Katrina and the Haiti earthquake in just like manner. I believe that was the driving force behind the posts if not fact of the matter.

  67. Velta says:

    In the article you quoted this:

    “The events described in Matthew 24:46,47 now refer to Jesus coming during the Great Tribulation and giving the Governing Body their reward in heaven along with the rest of the anointed.

    Do you suppose this means that when you become part of the Governing Body you automatically switch from the “great crowd class” to the “anointed” and you gain access to heaven?
    This new teaching opens up a big ‘can of worms’!

  68. Joe Doe says:

    The unnamed scholar spoken of on page 24, with regards to the “evil slave,” and the line quoted without providing reference: New English Translation: Novum Testamentum Graece, New Testament. Text and notes edited by Michael H. Burer, W. Hall Harris III et al. Greek text and critical apparatus Nestle-Aland. 27th edition. Stuttgart: Deutsche Bibelgesellaschaft, 2001; Dallas: NET Bible Press, 2004. http://www.netbible.com
    Several of the scholars involved are evangelical ministers, including M.H. Burer and W.H. Harris III.

  69. Joe Doe says:

    In addition to the previous posting regarding the accuracy of quotes from “worldly” scholars: the quote on page 24 with regards to the “evil slave” is taken from page 71, footnote #7 of the above mentioned book.

  70. Ted says:

    Ole ‘Drunken’ Joe was right about one thing when he said “Religion is a snare and a racket”. This article will open the eyes of many. Sometimes the “new light” may just be a train headed your way.

  71. Ted says:

    “Fear not those who kill the body (but can not destroy the soul)”
    I will buy a new Ferrari (with donations you forego)

  72. bryan says:

    Knowledge and truth
    The real truth
    Good stuff

  73. BeenMislead says:

    I have no reason to believe they are right with their interpretation of prophecy now. They have NOT got it right yet.
    Russell preached that:

    1799 – Was the Time of the End – or beginning of Last Days
    1874 – Was Christ’s Invisible Return
    1914 – Would be the End of System – Armageddon

    He was wrong!!
    Rutherford preached that:

    “Millions Now Living Will Never Die”
    1925 – Would be the End of System – Armageddon

    He was wrong!!
    The GB of the 60’s and 70’s said:

    - “If you are a young person you will never grow old in this present system of things.” (In 1969)
    - The generation of 1914 would not pass away until the end comes.
    - Strongly suggested that the end of the system would come on or around 1975.

    They were wrong!!

    Based on the above it would be naive, gullible, and irresponsible to believe that they are right now. In fact the more time goes by the more it is proving that the whole 1914 teaching is wrong!!

  74. I left the org this past Dec after being in for 53 years, since I was 3. Already went to a pastor and renounced my faith in ALL wt teachings. I came to this decision by reading a real bible, not the nwt. After telling those of my family still in, to read Ps145:3 Jer17:5 Ac5:29 lastly now my favorite verse in the whole bible, Lu21:8. I remember reading this scripture, but not after the word AND. Once I saw this even in their bible, I knew they were NOT of God. They are of satan, the way they came to be, with all the mysticism of Egypt and the outlandish ideas they had at the very beginning, should be enough to ward people off. Now that I look at the wts in a different light, I see just how deeply I was brain-washed by that cult. I looked up the meaning of cult, and was shocked to find out I was in one for so long. After finding out the truth about the ‘truth’ I find I love truth more than anything. I can’t go back…EVER! I am so happy to hear thousands leave every week. This is something you can ask a jw, why are jw’s in only 239 lands and Christianity is in over 3,000 lands. More people in the USA have bladder issues, 20 mil than there are jw’s on the whole earth! 8 mil. Does this mean that the 2k+ lands they aren’t in will die? Or does this mean, with the 1914 date, that you will never preach in all the inhabited earth? OR, I guess you were wrong about 1914…oh I forgot, now we are to look at these days as ‘just as in the days of Noah’, now means 120 years from 1914. Isn’t that longer than the generation of man being 80 years? Just saying.

    • Magusknight1974 says:

      I agree when I took classes in Psychology that I learn about the cult group。I also discovered that when you leave the veil your under your eyes are opened up wide. I will never save my family but at least I am free. For those that left your in a better place. I am in a much better place and I agree that when your mind is free so follows your spirit. They control all aspects of your life through fear and disappointment so you tow the line. I still have fear issues that derive from years of worship. I deal with it but to associate with witnesses still involved can really mess with your head. Protect yourself from their programmed answers like robots. Just come back and things will work out but when you free yourself going back is prison.

      • Hi, thank you for your encouraging words. I took a big step today, I washed the stain of the cult away, by getting baptized in a non-denominational church. I felt amazing afterward. I am now baptized in the name of Jesus. Not as a representative of a man made family destroying cult. All I kept doing was remembering the difference. No 80 questions, just ‘do you believe Jesus is the Son of God’. I am now with Christ in spirit. I have never felt such freedom in my life…Praise the Lord!

  75. John says:

    How lucky we are to live in the last days of this system of things, this new light is a spiritual meal that is meat in due season. The Faithful and Discreet slave has been determined as the governing body, which has clarified earlier teachings. The evil slave is Cedars for his apostate teachings and misquotes. In his 2012 survey, he concluded all those who don’t believe in the immortal soul are atheists, even though this is a teaching of Christendom, not the meat in due season being served by the Faithful and Discreet slave. He also does not appear to wear a tie, further evidence he is the evil slave.

    • Cedars says:

      John, you’re hilarious! I love that one of the pieces of evidence that I’m the “evil slave” is that I don’t wear a tie! :) That conclusion makes almost as little sense as the Watchtower article under discussion. After all, did Jesus wear a tie?

      On a serious note though, please try to make sense and be respectful when you are debating rather than resorting to ad hominem. We have a shiny new moderator now in the form of Admin Jeni, and it will be her job to protect the website from any needlessly nasty visitors. I would stay on her good side if I were you.

  76. JimmyG says:

    John, I’m not sure if you are taking the ‘P’ or not. If you’re not, your comment is meaningless and as is usual of JW drones also includes an ad hominem attack on an individual. The ‘new light’ articles in the July 15 WT has more holes in it than Swiss cheese. You appear miraculously to know who the ‘evil slave’ is as well!

  77. musicman4283 says:

    I assumed John’s comment was a sarcastic joke. I figured that “no tie = evil slave” had to be sarcasm, but then again with so many other such crazy theological ideas being disseminated from the Watchtower, who knows what the JWs are capable of believing. In other words, JWs are so crazy that it becomes hard to tell if someone is making a joke or if they are a Watchtower zealot. Lol

    • Elizheva says:

      I think that people need to make a distinction between the Watchtower organization and its members because someone who serves Almighty God Jehovah, regardless of the organization’s mistakes, is acceptable to Almighty God. Acts 10:34 So Peter opened his mouth and said: “Truly I understand that God shows no partiality, 35 but in every nation anyone who fears him and does what is right is acceptable to him. Luke 12:48 But the one who did not know, and did what deserved a beating, will receive a light beating.

  78. Lu21:8 says it best. Do not be misled, many will come saying I am the Christ, AND the end is near at hand. DO NOT FOLLOW AFTER THEM. God also forethought to warn us in Ps146:3. DO NOT put your faith in that of earthling man to whom NO salvation belongs. The only way to the Father is thru the Son, not a gb of old men who hide pedophiles from it’s members!

    • John says:

      Quoting bible verses out of context never says it best, your own wisdom and perhaps a summary of a bible chapter with your own interpretation of what it teaches us would say far more. This chapter is about the destruction of the temple in the year 70, and how his disciples show not lose faith even when things like war and earhtquakes occur. And indeed his people have not lost faith, even the Pope has resigned, perhaps because his knew this light would convince all that it is the Governing Body of Jehovah’s witnesses that have the truth. He spoke highly of the group to his nephew, who is one of the anoited.

      • Elizheva says:

        Romans 2:6 God “will repay each person according to what they have done.”
        Matthew 13: 24 Another parable He put forth to them, saying: “The kingdom of heaven is like a man who sowed good seed in his field; 25 but while men slept, his enemy came and sowed tares among the wheat and went his way. 26 But when the grain had sprouted and produced a crop, then the tares also appeared. 27 So the servants of the owner came and said to him, ‘Sir, did you not sow good seed in your field? How then does it have tares?’ 28 He said to them, ‘An enemy has done this.’ The servants said to him, ‘Do you want us then to go and gather them up?’ 29 But he said, ‘No, lest while you gather up the tares you also uproot the wheat with them. 30 Let both grow together until the harvest, and at the time of harvest I will say to the reapers, “First gather together the tares and bind them in bundles to burn them, but gather the wheat into my barn.”’”
        Micah 6:8 He has shown you, O mortal, what is good. And what does the LORD require of you? To act justly and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God.
        Matthew 9:12 On hearing this, Jesus said, “It is not the healthy who need a doctor, but the sick. 13But go and learn what this means: ‘I desire mercy, not sacrifice.’ For I have not come to call the righteous, but sinners.”

  79. KtotheRad "Konrad" says:

    Many people on this forum have commented on making a distinction between The Governing Body and Elders, “The Organization” and Jehovah’s Witnesses as individuals.

    I also have tried to make points in veiled fashion but have never directly stated the before the signifgance of the entities.

    daniel in Chapter 12 and verse 4 prophesied as to how ot would be in the end in this respect:

    “4 But thou, O Daniel, shut up the words, and seal the book, even to the time of the end: many shall run to and fro, and knowledge shall be increased.” KJV

    The NWT renders the “Many shall run to and fro and knowlege shall be incresed” as “Many shall rove about and the true knolwlege will become abundant”.

    This indicates that even as there are brutal crimes and a false heirarchy of criminal oppression of the sick and weak, unsriptural judiciary in Pharisee fashion, deception and falshood as well as “The man of lawlessness” being revealed that one can expect in accord with Matthew 24:45-51 the “Evil Slave” is pretty clear.

    45 Who then is a faithful and wise servant, whom his lord hath made ruler over his household, to give them meat in due season?

    46 Blessed is that servant, whom his lord when he cometh shall find so doing.

    47 Verily I say unto you, That he shall make him ruler over all his goods.

    48 But and if that evil servant shall say in his heart, My lord delayeth his coming;

    49 And shall begin to smite his fellowservants, and to eat and drink with the drunken;

    50 The lord of that servant shall come in a day when he looketh not for him, and in an hour that he is not aware of,

    51 And shall cut him asunder, and appoint him his portion with the hypocrites: there shall be weeping and gnashing of teeth.

    On the other hand, Daniel as quoted provided the basis for fundamental Bible Truths having been taught to many. I for one would never have learned about the ransom, resurrection or paradise earth in spite of all the brutal and indescribable crimes, pain and abuse that I was forced to experience and witness others have to endure had not I been contacted by one of Jehovah’s Witnesses.
    It is true that many individual “Jehovah’s Witnesses” are loyalists, the so called “Die Hards” to the organization and not to Jehovah and therefore don’t belong to Jehovah and never did. They belong to The organization and that’s where they should be. Could they be willingly managed or controlled in a new world of loyal order and peace? They will never see the reality of things nor accept them for what they are and they deserve everything they get since they always had the Bible right there in their hands. It told them where their worship was to be directed. They are no less accountable than anyone else for misguided and improper worship whatever their motives and possibly moreso given the knowlege and insight that they have.

    “Judgement begins with the house of God”

  80. John says:

    You have misspelled knowledge twice. This appears to indicate you don’t have much. You are clearly not receiving meat in due season as you ramble a lot without making any clear points. It should be clear to you by now that this parable is about internal dissension, as yourself and Cedars would both have the Governing Body supplanted, but are not unfriendly to the principle doctrine of the Congretations of Christian Witnesses of Jehovah. Any attempt to supplant these discreet men can only be seen by accepting that anyone that tries to do so in an evil slave, and this is revealed in the very verses you quote.

  81. musicman4283 says:

    Using your logic, there is no reason for the existence of any organization at all. Why be a member of an unnecessary and unbiblical organization? Why settle for just a “light beating” when you can disassociate and receive no beating at all? We all know about “bad associations,” of which I consider membership to the Watchtower as being one of them. If you don’t want to be viewed by others in light of your membership, then disassociate and you will no longer have that “bad association.”

    On a side note, looks like John was actually serious with his comment about Cedars being the “evil slave.” That is just absurd and demonstrates just how ridiculous some members can be. I certainly would not want to be associated with any group that entertains such fanciful notions.

  82. KtotheRad "Konrad" says:

    For a man who just misspelled “Congretations” and claims to be a Jehovah’s Witness?
    I wouldn’t make many claims right now…

    Why aren’t you out in service instead of hanging out on an apostate site and abusing people whom you can’t refute?

    I don’t have the benefit of a spell check since I was forced to shut down my home Internet due to the very real threat of being hacked by your Watchtower Society operatives which was all reported to the authorities.

    Here, read this whole thread wise guy:


    I do the best I can by just winging it on a public computer so what’s your excuse?

  83. KtotheRad "Konrad" says:

    “Using your logic, there is no reason for the existence of any organization at all. Why be a member of an unnecessary and unbiblical organization? Why settle for just a “light beating” when you can disassociate and receive no beating at all? We all know about “bad associations,” of which I consider membership to the Watchtower as being one of them. If you don’t want to be viewed by others in light of your membership, then disassociate and you will no longer have that “bad association.”

    My logic? Where are there my quotes in there? I told you what the scriptural basis was for the existing circumstances and I told you that I would not have learned the basic Bible Truths if it had not been for Jehovah’s Witnesses.

  84. musicman4283 says:


    Sorry, you misunderstand. My comment was for Elizheva not you. For some reason, my ipad does not post comments as a reply but a whole new comment, don’t know why. I will have to refrain from posting unless on my desktop to prevent miscommunications like this one. Your comments are very informative and I enjoy reading them.

  85. KtotheRad "Konrad" says:

    “Sorry, you misunderstand”

    Okay, sorry as well…It’s an inherent flaw of this site as well that replies don’t always designate who they are supposed to go to!

  86. KtotheRad "Konrad" says:

    John April 30, 2013 at 11:50 am

    “Apologies, I meant congregations, and at least I’m big enough to admit my bias, whereas you are evidently from some other denomination and are not disclosing which one, although your “DieHards” reference would appear to indicate you are a Scientologist and worship Bruce Willis. I am in service right now, attempting to help you find your way back to the Truth, which can only be found in the meat in due season served by the Governing Body of Jehovah’s Witnesses. Konrad you are employing a variety of excuses, your reason for nonsensical drivel appears to be “I don’t have a computer, I am a victim, ad honimen attack on me, and an attempt to send me to a website laden with tracing cookies dressed up as being anti-hacking defence”. When your quotes of other people (including books) are longer than what you have to say, you have nothing worth saying.”

    Whatever it is…that you have said here…(and I can only hope that you at least know what that is)…will be given the due consideration it deserves! (- :

  87. John says:

    In essence, don’t blame me that you have so little knowledge that your job apparently involves quoting the Bible on an internet forum.

  88. KtotheRad "Konrad" says:

    John April 30, 2013 at 12:12 pm

    “In essence, don’t blame me that you have so little knowledge that your job apparently involves quoting the Bible on an internet forum”

    In essence, if you keep coming back here and attacking people, especially Cedars after you’ve been asked by more than one person to quit? Don’t be surprised if you are banned and your posts deleted. It’s happened before.

  89. John says:

    I was just trying to re-educate you in the ways of Truth (I notice you didn’t answer my question. Threatening to have Cedars ban me is the equivalent of threatening to tell your mummy or taking your ball home. I have merely been trying to clarify what we are being taught by the article.

  90. Kyp says:

    Everyone who believes this words about Rutherford should read the minutes of Moyle’s hearing in presence and with Rutherford and what he had to say about alcohol, his “luxury” and bad speech. Then judge again on your own.

  91. It is also for today…everything in the bible is a foreshadow of today. And I hardly expect those who follow earthling man to their death would understand.

  92. You learned THEIR doctrines from a Satanist transcribed bible. Look up Johannes Greber and his spirit medium wife. It’s in the Aid book, but not the insight book. New light? yeah right!

  93. KtotheRAD "Konrad" says:

    I can’t threaten you with anything…This is Cedars’ site and he has the authority to do as he pleases. I would and did advise you that when you are invited into someone’s private website, that they paid and labored to setup for people to use, just as when you are invited into their home that you observe the same courtesy and not get butt kicked out the door as I have seen others who act as you have done!
    I think I have been rather polite and patient in taking your abuse and watching you dish it out to others so “Threatening” is hardly how I would view it. I thought it was a kind gesture on my part but you apparently have very little appreciation for that…or much!

    • john says:

      Johannes Greber was a truth seeking Christian in the tradition of Jehovah’s Witnesses. I apologise for seeming threatening, it was not intended. @Elizheva You know you’re on an American forum when you get a reply consisting entirely of Bible quotes.

  94. Elizheva Lau says:

    Yes, bible verses are sufficient because God’s word doesn’t require personal commentary.

    Hebrews 4:12 For the word of God is alive and active. Sharper than any double-edged sword, it penetrates even to dividing soul and spirit, joints and marrow; it judges the thoughts and attitudes of the heart.

  95. KtotheRAD "Konrad" says:

    “but then again with so many other such crazy theological ideas being disseminated from the Watchtower, who knows what the JWs are capable of believing. In other words, JWs are so crazy that it becomes hard to tell if someone is making a joke or if they are a Watchtower zealot. Lol” ~ Quite right musicman and John’s statement taht anyone who attempts to supplant the Governing Body is “The Evil Slave” is pure Watchtower propaganda when the scripture clearly states this:

    45 Who then is a faithful and wise servant, whom his lord hath made ruler over his household, to give them meat in due season?
    46 Blessed is that servant, whom his lord when he cometh shall find so doing.
    47 Verily I say unto you, That he shall make him ruler over all his goods.
    48 But and if “THAT” evil servant shall say in his heart, My lord delayeth his coming;

    It is clearly the same entity who has a changed condition in God’s eyes.

  96. dino says:

    Something about their financial machinations. On page jw.org are encouraged to give contributions because they are needed for the construction of halls in poor countries. And as post-war Bosnia when they should build the hall said that the Society is to build, but we owe it to repay the monthly installments. Then carried out a survey at the time of the meeting, to write down on paper and put it in an envelope how much money you are willing to separate the month for a new hall. Of course the exhilaration brothers have written and what I can and what can not. Today this same hall they want to sell because they were from Zagreb (leaders) bought land outside the city for a new hall. You can imagine again asking for money at the meeting and they say if you do not have, to sell something valuable from the house (local elders encouraged) eg necklace jewelry, etc. to give a contribution to Jehovah’s house. The ultimate arrogance. And so the Watchtower Society earning three times in one hall. How do first time on page jw.org us to make contributions because the money used to build the hall in poor countries. Other times when the immediate need to make room, encouraging members as they prepared to separate the month for the hall. And the third time this hall sale that supposedly do not have enough money for the new that is complete. What fraudsters. Is this the Faithful and Discreet Slave.

  97. Jasper Santiago says:

    The WT-study article version dated July 2013 has not reached us in our local congregation. However, July 2013 issues of WT and Awake for public consumption are already available for distribution. I am wondering why there is a delay in shipment. It makes me speculate so more.

  98. Anon says:

    Truly one of the most nonsensical statements ever made by the WTS:

    “Note, however, that the word “slave” in Jesus’ illustration is singular, indicating that this is a composite slave.”

    In other words:

    ‘Note the word is SINGULAR, indicating MULTIPLE people.’

    How do people swallow this garbage??

  99. john says:

    Indeed, this shows that light gets brighter and explains why Bible Students initially thought Russell was the slave. I’m sure the faithful and discreet slave know more about the nuances of Ancient Greek grammar than you, they did translate the Bible after all.

  100. issac says:

    One thing is for sure. The 1st Governing body never knew they were being selected by Jesus itself, otherwise they (1st GB) would have documented it in there writings. Only after so much of revisions (present) jw came to know this truth. Amazing.

  101. Reader says:

    The “disgusting” United Nations – a former partner

    The UN has come under fire from Watchtower publications repeatedly over the decades, but rarely has the denunciation been so forthright as in this latest magazine. On page 4 in the first study article, Witnesses are reminded that the United Nations, which is declared to be the modern-day “disgusting thing,” WILL attack Christendom and the rest of “false religion” to signal the outbreak of the Great Tribulation.

    The poor U.N. trying and often failing but trying non the less.
    But I do NOT reason it to be the ‘Disgusting Thing’ of Daniel 11 v 31b. The ‘Disgusting Thing’ here is I think the ‘Trinity dogma’ in Christendom, compare Daniel 11 v 32-34 to the Middle Ages.
    I got this on finding the Ships of Kittim as being the ‘Battle of the Masts’ followed by ‘greek fire’ [Arms], then the ‘Third Council of Constantinople : 680-681 A. D’ fully installed the trinity and quashed dispute.
    So they were/are ok as an NGO.
    More detail: put “Daniel Eleven Hyperlinked” into Google.

  102. Sergey FDS says:

    Cedars,вопрос о главном:
    уже в начале статьи вы пишите:”…авторы статей дают ключевым доктринальным моментам объяснения,которые в лучшем случае можно назвать безосновательными и голословными…”,но ведь считается,что Руководящий Совет даёт те или иные разъяснения и дополнения под руководством святого духа Иеговы.
    Каким “духом” вам, лично, открыта ваша позиция противоположная духу Руководящего Совета?
    Не приведёт ли это к противодействию с вашей стороны воле Иеговы Бога,а в дальнейшем к уничтожению как служителя сатаны,дьявола?!
    Спасибо за ответ,если он прозвучит.

  103. john says:

    I have already been banned from this website so why comment on such an old post pretending that you allow debate while simultaneously stifling it. I think Konrad is admitting apostates are the evil slave in his statement, thereby agreeing with me. The EU has already begun to attack Christianity, you should get out more Reader, the time of the end has begun! May you be spared the passing of this system of things.

  104. KtotheRAD "Konrad" says:

    “I think Konrad is admitting apostates are the evil slave in his statement, thereby agreeing with me”

    You think? No, That is the question in itself, You…Think?

  105. john says:

    I think you are missing an auxiliary verb in your question and the capitalisation of the verb you have used is superfluous. Next time read a dictionary before going back to the flawed Sola Scriptura system. You may learn something.

  106. KtotheRAD "Konrad" says:

    john July 26, 2013 at 4:55 am

    “I think you are missing an auxiliary verb in your question and the capitalisation of the verb you have used is superfluous. Next time read a dictionary before going back to the flawed Sola Scriptura system. You may learn something”

    Either that or I’m simply trying to emphasize the word in absence of italics or other ability to highlight features…
    As someone who actually has a measure of post-secondary education and was forced to sit every night at the dinner table with a father who was a school teacher, I recommend that you don’t even head off in that direction. It’s a losing wager!
    You seem to have this “win at all cost” attitude, in spite of the facts that is not going to serve you well…It may do okay in that organization in the short term, very short term but not in life. Any sensible person would be able to see the road signs and the impending cliff ahead. If anybody needs to do some reading, I would say those signs would be a good place to start.

  107. john says:

    He was the teacher of lawlessness and you are the priest of a lie.

  108. Faithful Witness says:

    It is sad to see all the comments people are making to attack each other. I am so grateful to have found this website! Thank you for your efforts.

    I have been led away from the watchtower, after several years of dedicated study. I was and still am, actively seeking the truth about Jehovah and His true desires for us. The WTS exposed itself to us as a false prophet, right at a pivotal time in our spiritual growth. I had to stop lying to our friends at the KH. We stopped going to meetings, but unfortunately, my parents and my sister (and her family) are still in the organization. My mother is not yet baptized, but the rest are. My sister has decided to shun me, but my father still talks to me. My parents still hope we will return.

    While I have been effectively silenced for about two years, I am now feeling a strong desire to witness to them. My new life in Christ has transformed me, and I was looking for tools or info I could use to start planting seeds of doubt for my parents. After searching apostate websites for help, I decided one day to go to the JW.org website and see what was being taught today. (I know they won’t take anything but WT approved publications… Let them speak for themselves!) …

    Well… I felt like I hit the jackpot, when I went to the JW.org website and saw that this magazine was their most recent teaching. I’m assuming the average JW is too busy to study ahead, and it’s unlikely that my parents have taken the time to read this magazine yet. I had a local JW friend deliver an original copy to me, so I could see how a well-trained, born and raised JW was programmed to respond to this new light. I was stunned, when she was so happy about it. “Isn’t it exciting?? I love it when the light gets brighter!!”

    Please God, let my intelligent, grown adult parents see the falsehoods in this horrible twisting of your words. Help me rescue them from this powerful organization. We are so thankful for your mercy and forgiveness. Our mistakes and sins are many, and we do not deserve salvation. Thank you for the sacrifice of your son, Jesus Christ, so that we may live and serve you forever.
    The watchtower has demonstrated for them, that it is okay to admit you are wrong and to change course. Help them please, Jehovah! They are trying to serve you, but are being deceived. Faithful followers of Christ can see these errors in prophecy, and we see the evil slave revealing itself blatantly to its followers. Guide me in my dealings with my parents, that I might say something to help them become aware of the spell to which they have succumbed. I stand here now, ready to serve your will. Direct me with your Holy Spirit, that I may make a difference and help those who are still lost.

    Cedars: thank you for this wonderful, timely analysis of this pivotal magazine. I think it may have come at the perfect time to reach my family and friends, even if only with a small doubt, as they continue to strive to be better JW’s. (my dad publicly declared this to our family, as his main focus in life: the be a good JW. … To which I replied, “Did you mean to say, ‘to serve Jehovah, or the JW’s?’”

  109. john says:

    I am sorry to hear you may been mislead…because this new light merely clarifies a long held doctrine of JWs (the infallibility of the Governing Body). I am glad you read ahead on the blessed website jw.org, but be warned on gourging on manna as the Israelites did. Instead, wait on Jehovah to provide meat in due season and you will not go wrong. May God bless you.

  110. Irene says:

    Great article. The arrogance of the Governing body is well noted. “They are now self-appointed representatives, not of heaven-bound Christians, but of Christ himself. They answer to no one, not even Christ whom they represent! After all, they have made his decision to appoint them over “all his belongings” for him in advance.”

  111. John says:

    Really? I had heard he made the decision when he appointed Rutherford in 1919.

  112. 70wksofyrs says:

    I come back to comment on this article even though it was written months ago, because we studied it in the congregations this weekend.

    I agree with Irene, I really like following the point you made……………..

    How can the Governing Body justify insisting that they WILL be appointed by Christ over “all of this belongings” in advance of this event? (p.25) – As discussed above, many sincere Witnesses will be left scratching their heads at the brazenness of the Governing Body in insisting they WILL be appointed by Christ over his belongings before he has even come in judgment. The decision has been effectively snatched out of Christ’s hands, and made for him.

    Thanks to this article and specifically this point, I was able to get my precious 11yr old to critically think on this doctrine and the contradiction between the watchtower articles in the magazine. It was great fun, we laughed we pondered and we questioned the GB.

    Cedars, you really are making progress. Since Feb 2013 there are three in our family who are coming to a better knowledge of TTATT. There must be many more also!!

    We just posed the questions…..
    1. So has Christ appointed the governing body or is he yet to appoint them?
    2. Who really is the faithful discreet slave?

  113. KtotheRAD "Konrad" says:

    john says:

    May 2, 2013 at 4:29 am

    “Johannes Greber was a truth seeking Christian in the tradition of Jehovah’s Witnesses”

    The one and only post that (J) or little (j) john (depending on his mood) ever made on which I can wholeheartedly concur!

    Here is an independent source but I strongly recommend further and deeper research into the topic of that very “tradition”:

    [Link removed - see posting guidelines]

  114. Cesar Rubio says:

    [This comment was deleted along with a silly comment about Obama being the AntiChrist. Please don't spam our site. Thank you. - Cedars]

  115. shandylord says:

    you must be a very studious person.for that I envy you.you have not stated who the ‘faithful and discreet slave’ should be.second the leaked magazine was eventually sent out to members without changes not because it wanted to be kept secret but because there were other materials already prepared prior to this ‘leaked magazine to be digested so it must just take some reasonable amount of time.third,(as an advice)to make people hate the the governing body,you must work harder than this,i mean putting more of your money,time,preaching from house to house,organising local and international conventions around the globe about your views.I bet you mere thinking about this will land you in the grave.put your talent to good use because the time left is reduced.

  116. Jorge says:

    Great reasoning. The “wheat” throughout those 19 centuries somehow had God’s approval without the “slave” (Watchtower) interpreting Bible truths. Reminds me of Job who was not part of the nation of Israel yet was the most upright man on earth at one time.

  117. john says:

    I shocked and completely confused
    Extremely disappointed
    I need help in controling my emotions
    My step father died because he didnt take a diayellss cleansing of his blood because the elders in middletown ny 10940 mount hope rd did not tell him it was not a sin/
    My mom is stranded in assited living/
    My family can not, will not speak to me
    I didnt finish college because i pioneered instead.
    I am completely cash poor
    Almost 50 lonely
    And dont know if the lady that raised me is my birth mother or not or who my dad was/is
    Why lie to people who are confused?
    Why not just close them down and payback ceasers things to ceaser
    Like we all do
    375Million$ is and insullt to all the voulenteers who worked on 90sands for free.
    They never even told me why they didnt call me to bethel.
    Anyhow thanks for the information
    It hurst so much i am sad for those still in that mess like 99%of my “family” as i know it.
    If you like to help me..i must warn you i am hurting inside disasscotiated since 2004/2005 and i am completely gay.
    I never had sex with a woman
    No sex before marriage so i didnt
    Never a servant. Too timate or shy i was told too slow…etc.. not manly enough???? To late
    The only affection i understand now to eternity is sodnomy sex with adult mature men only i am a bottom /vers. I am at peace now.
    I have a gurdian. He watches me closely
    They put me in the metal hospital in1991/1992 becaise i asked. The elders questions i should have known the answers to.
    Like what is the evil slave class/how do you know you are one of 144000 /what are appostates/are we livingbin pardise or the last days/ did i greve the holy sprit/ ehat does the index finger mean when some one points it in the air? Etc,.. many more question like that….
    I was a JW since i was about two
    Or birth ??? But all my.life only the kingdom hall.
    She was baptized in1968 (“mother”)
    Its sad she 89and all alone? Kind of mean when i asked her about the time we are living in she sounds as confused as i do……
    Sad she never got disfelliship once
    But i cant be with her as it can cause her to greive the holy sprit do not be mislead bad associtaion spoils useful habitts…..,
    I think i will just listen to my guardian only Jehovah wittness abadoned me in the.metal hospital told.me to take meds and that basically was all i got for being loyal shame and diponment no support system at all.
    My gaudisn is gay and owns a porn company he protects me from lirs at humilation of prejudusiou negleful lieing hypocrits.
    We have the exact same birth date born teo different years
    I trust him/have to legally
    I hope all the best to all
    But for me i know i am in pardise
    I have peace and foucsed and calm
    I have a real God who loves me for me just as i am a gay man.
    Ps i sing very good…….

  118. StillShocked says:

    Weren’t a bunch of Bethelites disfellowshipped in the 80′s for saying that the anointed worldwide were not consulted by the Society for “new light” so how could the anointed be the “slave”? So the “apostates” had it right thirty-something years ago? We’re expected to believe Jehovah provided this new light nearly 100 years after Jesus’ enthronement?

  119. ced says:


    [Edit: Link removed. Sorry, but I'm not a believer in subliminal images in Watchtower publications, and this site won't be used to attract attention to links furthering that argument.]

  120. StillShocked says:

    I know why it took Jesus four and a half years from 1914 to 1919 to appoint the Slave. He was examining all the pedophilia files page by page at Headquarters. (Sarcasm noted).

  121. JBob says:

    Realizing I never left a hard-hitting commentary here… sigh–how did I ever make it through Sunday Watchtower Studies?

    So, now the scoop is out, the GB=FDS–the de facto is now documented and authorized teaching. A few assumptions in the July article were made to stucco the image of the GB smoothly being appointed in, or about, 1914–the early apostles had no challengers to authority, as they performed miracles. Point of fact, Jesus raised the dead, but did everyone believe? The apostle Paul cites numerous examples of persons challenges his qualifications as an apostle, and then, there’s that whole Acts 15:5, 6 (the inspiration for naming the GB in the first place) which spins on certain former Pharisees rising up and raising the spectre of being circumcised (and keeping the Sabbath–no, I just threw that in for the 7DA’s), which pulled together a council, not only of apostles but elders and bishops from the Jerusalem synod. So, counterpoint to the premise that no challenges, or question of “who really is the FDS” to be answered resolutely, was made in first century.

    Basically, what the Watchtower is laying the foundation to do is distance itself very promptly from certain weak points the current “helpers” and GB are finding in the foundations laid by the Advent Christian influences on Russell’s studies in scripture, even selling land that the founder purchased from H Ward Beecher’s church to establish Brooklyn Tabernacle. The new HQ being far, far away from this albatross and the other anvil in Pittsburgh where a pyramid headstone is lain.

    Speculation could abound on how the Watchtower will spin 1914 as the “turning point” and “beginning of the last days” and why such a delay to the final judgement, but if history repeats, it will follow a story arch similar to other Adventist groups in spinning 1844 expectations into a fulfillment, but based on 1914 AD. Mainly the same arguments used, now, which is “refining” and “this good news to be preached in all the earth”.

    Perhaps Henry A Grew will be available to provide these runaway “slaves” an underground route to liberation from their sordid history?

  122. john - banned says:

    Good to see new light on the United Nations being provided. It appears from this website that they’re not so bad after all and maybe apostates are the whore of Babylon. Interesting, we will see.

Add Comment Register

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>


Comment posting guidelines:

Kindly observe the following requirements before posting any comments to our articles or pages:

  • ABUSIVE COMMENTS - Do not post comments that include swear words or may be considered abusive, lewd, blasphemous, obscene or threatening
  • ILLEGAL COMMENTS - Do not post comments that condone or propose illegal activity, or that breach copyright law
  • OFF-TOPIC COMMENTS - Do not post comments that are off-topic and bear no relation to the page or article
  • RELIGIOUS NEUTRALITY - Do not post comments that are evangelical in nature or may be construed as imposing one person's religious beliefs (or lack thereof) over those of another
  • LANGUAGE - Visitors from all countries and language groups are welcome. You may post comments in languages other than English, but we would appreciate if you could make any such comments brief. We would also be grateful if you could run any such comments through Google Translate and convert these to English, but this is not an absolute requirement.
  • LINKS - You may post links to third party websites, so long as (1) you limit these to 2 links per comment, and (2) the content on these links doesn't contravene ANY of the first four points. Specifically, you may not post URLs to websites that are evangelical in nature. Our links page has an extensive list of such sites for any who are curious about Christian beliefs in the context of Jehovah's Witnesses.

JWSurvey.org thanks all visitors in advance for respectfully observing these guidelines. Any who persistently fail to do so, despite warnings, may find themselves blocked from making further comments at the discretion of the site moderators, whose decision will be final and not open for debate.